Reviews for Island Kitchen in Nantucket, MA
Nice breakfast. Went for “the animal” breakfast sandwich with fresh side of potatoes and it hit the spot. Good coffee too.
We went to celebrate my birthday and had the most wonderful time!! The food was delicious. The atmosphere was warm, festive and... unpretentious. The service was attentive. We ordered a bottle of rose and split the goat cheese apple salad (without bacon), theartichoke dip, and the pickled vegetables. For entrees we had the spicy tuna bowls and miso salmon. They surprised me with abirthday brownie. We'll definitely be returning. Read more
We decided to try this for a late breakfast based on the reviews and then we were terribly disappointed. The hostess was far... from welcoming, no Hello, etc. After sitting for about 15 minutes, I had to ask if we had a waitress and the hostess had to gofind her. The waitress did not check in on us once. Not only was the service terrible, but the food was mediocre at best. TheFrench toast was pretty good and the egg white scramble was good, but the breakfast tacos did not taste like they had chorizoand everything else was average at best. Don’t recommend wasting your time or money. Read more
Great service, nice ambiance, food was just ok. The service: Hostess was very friendly and accommodating. We had a reservation... for outdoor uncovered which are the wood benches in front of the restaurant. It was a hot day and we asked for a table inside.She very kindly pulled a few tables together to seat our party of 6. Our waitress was provided top service. She didn’t miss abeat on anything. This place definitely has top notch service all around. The ambiance: Beautiful restaurant with a coveredpatio/garden that was very nice. The food: I ordered the Summer Risotto with Lobster and my husband ordered the Pork Loin.Risotto lacked flavor, the consistency was right and there was a lot of it. The lobster on top was over cooked. The pork loinwas not tender and a bit dry. Read more
Good food and drinks, the atmosphere is great, and they take reservations online. If you come at a rush hour time or on a big... weekend you may have to wait longer for your food because they have a lot of tables and staffing is hard on Nantucket but theservers themselves are very nice and so accommodating. We had the Chicken Milanese and the burger and both were fantastic. Read more
Best spot for ice cream on the island… this is not downtown, so you really need a car to get here, but this is my opinion is... the best ice cream on island. The flavors are unique and very tasty and each time I have gone in we have had great service. If you can venture out of town this place is a must try! Read more
Island Kitchen has this great reputation from many many years ago , unfortunately this season i am not satisfied as i use to... be. We use to have great experience and really tasty food, but not anymore. Atmosphere is great - cute garden , really chillvibe. Service is slow, really slow this season 2021. We had to go look several times for our servers. The last time there ourserver did not even check ones on us ... so sad . Thanks God for the food runners - school kids , they was the best workingreally hard!!! There are not many breakfast options on the island and i hope they step up back in the game with the taste andservice. See you again next season !!! Good luck ???? Read more
Love love love!!! We found this place on a rainy Sunday to be just exactly what we needed for a late breakfast. We ordered the... Panko Eggs Benedict and the Turkey Hash with eggs. Both were fantastic!! The service was fast and friendly (thanks, Anastasia!)and the wait time was minimal. This place had a very relaxed island vibe. We can't wait to try the Bloody Mary's next time!!! Read more