Reviews for Foggy Nantucket in Nantucket, MA

Best experience of my life. I will forever remember the kind lady at Foggy?s pizza who hand delivered my cheese pizza in the... midst of a hurricane. It?s a story I?ve told my children and will tell my grandchildren. It started with my pizza order. It justhappened that the delivery services would not work that day for my pizza, and I couldn?t drive to pick up my pizza because alady had boxed my car in. The precious angel that worked at Foggy?s understood my problem and decided out of the kindness of herheart to drive my pizza out to me. She didn?t have to do this, but she did. I haven?t even tasted the pizza yet, but the workerstill deserves five stars. Read more

Awesome Pizza! Great service for such a small place! All I can say is this is the place to get your Pizza fix!

OMG- you must try this pizza! It is amazing. We had the pineapple and the garlic on it took it to the next level!

Pizza was delicious, crispy/chewy crust. Green goddess salad dressing that came with the power salad should be bottled and sold... separately- it was amazing! And the raspberry donut cheesecake-total Yum. Service was great too, order ready on time andfriendly service. Read more

Service is an absolute train wreck. I?ve ordered from them a few times and they always screw something up completely. Most... recently we ordered pizza for delivery. Two slices of cake and marinara (nice combo) showed up with no pizza. Called them backand they rudely said they would put the pizza in the oven and have it delivered as if we were inconveniencing them. Well itnever showed up and they stopped answering their phone. I would recommend Foggy to anyone who?s not hungry, but loves to throwmoney in the trash. Wish I could give them 0 stars. Read more

Everything is absolutely amazing. Couldn?t stop eating even when full. The mac and cheese is delectable. Brisket was... mouthwatering. Pulled pork was delicious. Cannot say enough good things. Read more

Very greasy deep dish pizza. When I picked up a slice, the cheese and the toppings fell right off! The garlic knots were lacking... flavor. Overall very disappointed. The picture shows what was left the next day which no one was interested in eating. Sogreasy!! Read more

I stopped by looking for the bakery that used to be here. At first I was worried because BBQ and bakery didn't go together in my... mind. However, I'm glad Foggy Bakery is there now! Their breakfast bakery stuff is really fantastic. I got a sample selectionincluding a sticky bun, foggy bun, cinnamon bun, chocolate croissant, and a little chocolate cheesecake treat. The sticky bunand Foggy bun were amazingly good. They are probably the best bakery items on the island right now. Really Fantastic. Thechocolate croissant and the cinnamon bun were very good. I haven't eaten any of the cheesecake thing yet. I would have includedmore pictures but my family ate everything but the cheesecake before I could write my review. I didn't try the BBQ food or thebreakfast burritos because I was on a bakery morning run for the family however I'll be coming back next year when I'm onisland. Read more