Reviews for Brotherhood of Thieves in Nantucket, MA
It was a pleasure experiencing The Brotherhood of Theives while in Nantucket yesterday. The service was great, the food was... excellent ???? Meeting Jamie was fantastic. Read more
It was around 8 on a crowded Tuesday night in mid-September so we ate upstairs in one of the three bars. Glad we did - found two... seats right away. It was still busy but a little quieter than the main bar and dining area. We shared a burger, a salad and acouple of drinks. The food was good, Stan is a fun bartender, and the bill was reasonable. Read more
Food was good nothing out of the ordinary I had the burger with the curly truffle fries and it was good. And my friend has the... lobster roll he said he’s had better but it was good. Read more
Really col place - delicious food - obviously a bit on the pricier side, but it's Nantucket. The sushi in particular was... fantastic Read more
Great new addition to the downtown scene. Food was great. Boom boom shrimp was exceptional. Prices are reasonable.
This was an old favorite spot we were sad to see shut down a few season ago… but they are back and it is good. It is one of... the better lunch or dinner values on the island. We had the wings, burgers and fish and chips and everything tasted great…the Burger is hands down my favorite. The drinks were also really good! We had heard rumors of it being slow and we did notthink so at all and and we had amazing service from our waitress. We will be going back again. Read more
One of the best taste and price values on island. The sushi was excellent. The staff is attentive and friendly. Service was... awesome. On e of the best burgers on island. The recent renovation makes the overall experience even better. Read more
Absolutely delicious. Cool atmosphere inside and incredible food, everything tasted fresh and flavorful. Was not expecting sushi... at a place like this but it was so good! My husband and I shared a roll between our mains. Highly recommend you do the same! AndI definitely recommend their cookie dessert. Will be coming back the next time we’re in Nantucket! Read more