Reviews for Sugar Creek Seafood Restaurant in Nags Head, NC

Food was good with good quality for the price. Waitresses and hostess were very friendly. Very understanding considering we... were eating with am infant. Great views for lunch. Will return when we come back this area Read more

The best sunsets around. The food was great, but they were out of cornbread and pasta. Our waitress was extremely friendly, ... she apologized abput the bread, but to be fair we arrived late in the evening. The seafood Quesadilla was out of thisworld. Cheers Read more

Came in just in time for a magnificent sunset! Had a party of five and we had the whole shebang, cocktails, apps, dinners and... desserts. Staff was very friendly and accomodating.. Food was delicious and expertly prepared. The fried green tomatoes,scallops and crab cakes were delish. Highly recommend saving room for dessert. Read more

The service was friendly and attentive but the cooking was mediocre. My fish was overcooked and dry, and the shrimp were also... tough. Not a lot of flavor. The scallops and the baked potatoes were the best items we ordered. The fried green tomatoes weredrenched in Thai sweet hot sauce, so you couldn't taste the tomatoes. I would reduce the sauce and stirfry the bed of cabbagethey were served on or shift to a remoulade sauce. However, the cornbread and hushpuppies appetizers were excellent. We likedthe Sunday bloody Mary cocktails. Read more

Pet (dog) friendly on the deck. They had great service, An awesome view on the deck! We ordered the calamari and the "Steamer... for 2" The calamari was SOOO Good! It was cooked perfectly with just the right amount of crispy batter that wasn't too heavy andat a great price! The reduction of the star was for the "Steamer for 2" they gave one corn and a single row of crab legs (4legs 1 claw) should of had even numbers so you don't need to ???? ???? ?? for the uneven items. Also The flavor was very muteand tasted like everything was boiled in just plain water, with a little dash of Cajun seasoning on the top. Read more

One of my new favorite restaurants in OBX! Food was delicious and the view was gorgeous. We sat on the porch so it was even... better. I had the catfish and it was amazing! The corn bread tasted homemade! Read more

Very friendly staff. Food was delicious..we came for the Easter buffet.. good variety & everything moved smoothly even though... they were quite busy. Great view of the sound & prices were reasonable Read more

Very good food and the waitress was friendly! They have really good early bird dinners and you get a lot of food for your moneys... worth. Plus they give you free cornbread. Despite the waitress forgetting to put my order in, she offered me a free dessertwhich was a chocolate pie, that was delicious. Beautiful views of the water as well. Read more