Reviews for Pagliai's Pizza & Italian Restaurant in Murray, KY

Love the drive-thru. Ordered pizza on the way home & 20min later we were picking it up fresh & hot.

FYI- No buffet on Mondays or Tuesdays. Prices on menu do not match what you are charged. We ordered four of the $5 eight inch... pizzas, Tuesday?s daily special. Menu stated thick or thin crust, and included 2 toppings. They rang up $4.60 each (for the thinones) plus almost a dollar each topping, for a total of about $6.50 each. But the thick crust we ordered rang up $8.78, notincluding the toppings! The pizza did not taste very good. My teenagers said they liked their school?s pizza and/or frozen pizzabetter. When I asked the lady at cash register about price discrepancy, she said the owner had increased the prices, and thatshe?d adjust the price. But she only took 10% off. I loved this place in college but I will definitely choose another optionnext time I?m in Murray! Read more

Always a great pizza here! This is our favorite pizza place in Murray. Staff are always very helpful and cheerful.

Our first visit. A typical pizza place with typical items on the menu; sandwiches, wraps, salads and of course pizza. I... ordered a Ruben sandwich and my wife ordered a chicken wrap. Our orders came very quickly. My Ruben was made with processedcorned beef and my wife's chicken wrap was very low on the signature item. The food was good and reasonable but we have hadbetter. The service was very good. Read more

Pizza was average and you had to request someone to get drinks and ticket. Now it was a Sunday lunch and we could only sit in... the back. So hopefully it was just the time that I decided to visit. Read more

This is a really great place. Very nice for families or a group. They have a private room in the back for events. Just overall... a nice comfortable place to be. Read more

This was my first time going here, and it was great! We are the buffet. The food was fresh, and delicious! They even made a... special pizza for us that they didn't have on the buffet. The staff were all smiling and friendly. Great service. The diningroom was clean and a very comfortable atmosphere. And very fair priced. Looking forward to going back more now! Read more

Best Italian food in Murray. Everytime we are in town we have to stop by. I love the thick crust pizza. Ohh and you have to get... a side of Blue Cheese. Sooooo good. Read more