Reviews for Cummare’s in Murphysboro, IL

Popular place, they were quite busy. Food was delicious. Service was great for how busy they were. Will definitely be back... again. Read more

After a day of hiking we stopped in for what we hoped would be a quick pizza. After sitting down and only seeing 3 other tables... it seemed like a score..After waiting 5 minutes for a waitress to see us, the score was trickling into a snore. I ordered drinksfor the table and a Moscow mule (but only if you have mint), the waitress left and didn't return for 11 minutes.. before herreturn I was brought a Moscow mule without mint. Being there with my 3 restless kids I quickly ordered an appetizer platter anda pizza. Little did I know I would be waiting 38 minutes for an appetizer. It was exhausting. The waitress gave us nocommunication and seemed very unfriendly.. once we finished our appetizer I had my husband make sure the pizza was comingshortly after and sadly it wasn't. It was still 12 minutes out that my husband waited inside for. So I packed up my kids and wedrove 30 minutes with a burning hot pizza they saw but couldn't eat. Whew, .. all in all we waited 1 hour 5 minutes for apizza... the service was bad, but the food was good. For some reason I still paid for the mule. ..I know staffing is hard rightnow and my experience doesn't accurately represent cummares all the time but tonight was definitely a <1 star experience. But 4stars because I know how staffing can be! Read more

Chicken Parmesan is delicious! Small little mom and pop place, with homemade food. A good value for your money. I'll be... back. Read more

If you like sweet marinara sauce, dry bland Alfredo, and waiting forever to get your food this may be the place for you. Let's... just say the food didn't taste any better coming back up 45 mins later me and the person I was with both got extremely sick toour stomachs after eating here do not recommend. Read more

DON'T USE THE GRUBHUB APP OR THIS RESTAURANT WILL BAN YOU FOR LIFE AND NEVER LET YOU ORDER AGAIN. I ordered via Grubhub but had... to cancel it. I did so IMMEDIATELY after ordering -- as in, two seconds. I really mean immediately. I do not mean five minutesor even one full minute. Within seconds. They would not have had time to even get the dough out before I canceled. Either theydidn't see the cancellation or they decided to make the order anyways and they are punishing the customer for it. I placed anorder the next day, and the restaurant canceled it twice. I called to explain what happened and asked if I could please place myorder. I apologized for the misunderstanding but the employee was extremely rude and asked with an attitude, "are you sureyou're not going to cancel ut again?" I said no and explained again that I cancelled the order right away, so it shouldn't havebeen made and it was not my fault that it was. The employee was again rude and acted as though I was trying to scam theirrestaurant. If you place an order with this restaurant, you will not be allowed to cancel it even if you do so immediately.Ordered the wrong thing on accident? Wanted to add to your order? Nope. And if you do, they will never allow you to order thereagain and will treat you like a pariah and ban you for life for just using the Grubhub app the way the app was designed. Read more

Totally awesome. Fresh, tasty, and great service!

The food was delicious and I really liked it a lot. I?m coming back here! The Mac and cheese was delightful and stringy-Gavin... (age 9) Read more

Great little Italian restaurant. Small towns seem to have a lot of little gems like this. My wife and I had our first date in... one just like it in west Texas. On this occasion we stopped in for the lunch buffet before hitting the wine trail. The pizza andpasta were both great as was the service. I hear it gets crowded for dinner so reservations are encouraged. Read more