Reviews for Amici Restaurant in Mt Sinai, NY
Good food and very friendly staff. Nice atmosphere, efficient service.
I took my wife here recently for our 17 year anniversary. We were really looking forward to trying the food after passing by... this place several times. There is a very nice atmosphere when you walk in. We wanted to sit outside and liked that they had ahuge outdoor area in the rear of the location for outdoor dining plus live music. The live music gives you that feeling of aclassy place. But, I will cut to the chase. The food was quite disappointing. First we ordered calamari for an appetizer. Thisclearly was not fresh but frozen / box bought. The after taste was terrible. We never return food but this was one of those veryfew exceptions because it was just really terrible I hate to say. We then had them bring us mozzarella sticks instead and theywere still half frozen inside and obviously frozen / box bought as well. Honestly we?ve had much better mozzarella sticks atplaces like IHOP and Friendly?s were you know they are frozen box food. The quality of the appetizers were verydisappointing. Our dinners were not much better unfortunately. I got the chicken marsala and my wife got penne alla vodka pastaand shrimp parm . The chicken marsala ended up being two small pieces of chicken that tasted basically like microwaved chickenwith marsala sauce on top of a ton of pasta. My wife said her dinner was ?ok? but she?s had far better in other Italian placesand pizza places. In all fairness, the entree?s were at least better than the appetizers. For an Italian restaurant that chargespremium pricing (our 2 dinners and 1 appetizer and one drink were nearly $100.00 after tip), we expected far better.Unfortunately, and I hate to say it, but it was the worst Italian food restaurant I?ve ever had in a very long time. I wish Icould say the waitress was friendly, but she looked a bit annoyed and dialed it in. I know it?s not an easy job, dealing withthe public, I get it, but people do like to feel welcomed when they dine at a restaurant and not just another number / tabl Read more
The meals we had were delicious , Fried Calamari , PE Mussels and Veal Parmigiana served with spaghetti and tomato sauce and the... deserts were very generous also. Service was very attentive and premises was clean. Portions were generous and take homecontainers provided made the experience delightful. Read more
Great food. Hated the reason we went there but really great food and really great staff. Would love to go sometime for dinner... with a way better reason. Read more
I like to leave reviews when is good and when is bad and this place was a big disappointment. Good thing I don?t leave in the... area and was only staying in a hotel around for one night. I ordered take out Chicken Frances with spaghetti. When I arrived tothe hotel I realized they didn?t put no napkins and no utensils. Food was also terrible, I can make a better chicken Frances andI?m not even Italian. Btw the order was $29.00 but their menu says 22.00. I find that very very expensive for the quality of thefood. I was better off buying pizza or any other fast food. Don?t waste ur money here, it was a very big disappointment. Read more
This place was very nice. The price was good and the food was good as well. Portion size is good for the price. The inside was a... bit old and it seemed like it was very humid inside and the air conditioner was cranking. I will definitely go back again oneday. Read more
We sat outside on a Saturday afternoon. Was empty when we got there. But was filling up when we left around 6:30. Band was... getting ready to play. 4 of us had a relaxing meal with good food and friendly service. Read more
Fantastic eggplant parmigiana dinners tonight. The restaurant is always packed so we decided to pick up and eat at home. The... meals were ready when promised and were still hot when we got home. Missing the excellent service and ambiance of the restaurantbut the food was still outstanding. Next time we will make a reservation ?? Read more