Reviews for Ye Ole Fashioned Ice Cream & Sandwich Cafe- Mt. Pleasant in Mt Pleasant, SC

Lightning doesn?t strike twice. After buying an amazing Reuben Sandwich at the Trolley Road location in Summerville, I decided... to buy one again, but in Mt. Pleasant. It was the absolute worst! There were 3 slices of bread, a dab of sauerkraut, and 2slices of corned beef. More bread than anything. Summerville will get my business. Read more

50 people in line and had to wait at least 46 minutes for service. We finally ordered the "Super sundae"Sundae. Four sundaes in... one for $10.00. Absolutely delicious. It was well worth the wait. I'm definitely going back. Read more

We have been here twice now in a month and a half and I've gotten the banana split which is ridiculously huge that we all share.... Good tasting, ice cream and a fun atmosphere. Somewhere to go to relax after being at the beach all day and having dinner. Willalways come here when we vacation and recommended highly. Read more

We enjoyed our first visit so much we returned a second time :-) Ice cream was excellent quality with a large variety of... options. The burgers, chicken strips, fries and onion rings were top notch. They're special dipping sauce was a huge hit withour group! Staff was busy, friendly and quick to serve. Love seeing a well run local business thriving! Read more

This was the worst sandwich I?ve ever eaten in my entire life. I paid $6.09 for a burnt sandwich with turkey that wasn?t even... real meat. The Russian dressing must have been prepackaged because it was disgusting. I couldn?t even finish the meal because itwas that bad. On top of that, there must have been something in it that had hidden dairy because it ending up upsetting mystomach. I have never been more disappointed in a meal in my life. Read more

The Banana Split was amazing! Nice little place serving food and Ice cream! Definitely a must try! Many flavors to choose from.

I order a chicken filet sandwich for my daughter. She began eating once we got home and after a few bites in we realized... something didn?t seem right. As you can see in the pictures, the chicken was still raw in the middle. Please try to do better -we honestly love Ye Ole Fashioned, and hope this does not become the norm. Read more

I got some Ice cream from this place and it was great, I did have to stand in line for like 10 min but it is expected do to the... fact that the ice cream is their best seller ???????? . One piece of advice buy the banana split is awesome so delicious. Isworth the price. Read more