Reviews for Amalfi's Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria in Mt Pleasant, SC

6 of us went to dinner to celebrate a birthday and the table next to us (inside and upstairs) had 2 dogs with them. They put... them on the floor and they kept shaking...yuck, don't want dog hair in my dinner. Plenty of places to eat that have outsidepatios for dogs but this was definitely not the venue. They should not have been allowed to bring their dogs. Will neverreturn. Part 2....Fluffy and Muffy were not service dogs so don't insult me by stating they were. Service dogs are highlytrained and these animals were not behaved. I think the public should be advised if they are dining with dogs, upstairs on thesecond floor. I would rather spend money in a more sanitary facility. Keeping my one star rating. Read more

We loved this restaurant! Needless to say it was very afforadable even for a family. We liked everything in our meals, mostly... had seafood pastas and veal. You should definitely try this place. Our server was also great and understanding, she did verywell even though it was a bit late at night! Read more

Mmm...pizza! Antiquated interior and no bar but that chicken pesto pizza is unique to them. Otherwise, it's hit it or miss, but... they do mostly nail the pizzeria Italian itch, if that's what you wanna scratch. Read more

Absolutely fabulous! I knew we were in the right place as soon as we walked in at 6:45 on a July Saturday night. They sat us... down immediately and quickly brought us water, hot bread and a wonderful oil and vinegar dip. Appetizers and entries we'reperfectly prepared and very tasty. Waitstaff we're extremely welcoming, happy and prompt. We are looking forward to our nextvisit. Read more

Once a good Italian restaurant that is rapidly going downhill. We?ve been a longtime customer and enjoyed some great meals. The... last three visits were bad, very bad, and awful. There is no lobby or waiting area so people just stand there watching you eat.Crab soup was barely room temperature- not a good thing for a cream based soup. Calamari were over cooked and clung together inone big lump. Meatballs were ok. Ordered linguine with clams and told they were out of clams. Switched to gnocchi. Others at thetable had a mixed seafood dish and it had a clams in it. So much for being out of clams. The gnocchi was undercooked anddrowning in tomato sauce. The seafood dishes had very little seafood in them - 2 shrimp, 3 tiny clams with invisible clams, 3mussels two of which were empty and 5 tiny slices of calamari. All this was in a bowl on a bed of soggy bread. We are done withAmalfi?s and have taken it off our list of got to spots. There are many other good Italian restaurants in the area - don?t wasteyour money here. Read more

Very nice staff, very nice decor. I thought the food was somewhat mediocre. Nothing made me complain, nothing made me thrilled.... I did think they did a good job on the antipasto though. Read more

We?ve been going to Amalfi?s for years, we used to live down the street. The past two times we?ve come back in town though,... we?ve made sure to come by and were disappointed. We thought last time was a fluke, but unfortunately after this last time wewon?t be coming back. We came in an hour and a half before closing and the music was off, a few servers were sitting in theback and said someone would get us soon. Waited about 5 minutes while they still sat down and then we were seated. We ordered aCesar salad, but they were out of Cesar, and asked if Greek was fine instead. They didn?t tell us the Greek was more expensive,charged us for both at first, then took off the cheaper one. A little thing, but hits at customer service. One of our pizzaswas too doughy and undercooked so we had to send it back, the other was fine. We assume the chefs were annoyed because the pizzawe got back was thrown together with half the toppings of the original, picture below. They get two stars because our actualserver was good and the bread is tasty. Read more

We ate here last night on New Years Eve. The food, staff, and atmosphere was amazing. Their fresh bread with balsamic vinegar... and EVOO was spectacular and warm!!!! My husband ordered the spaghetti and meat balls and he cleaned his plate!!!! My chickenmarsala was awesome and such a huge portion I could not eat it all after the fresh bread and bruschetta we ordered. Thebruschetta was also very good with mounds of fresh tomatoes!!! We highly recommend this place, we will be back soon to check outthe pizza!!! Read more