Reviews for NY Pizzeria in Mt. Juliet, TN
Kids begged me for pizza after target and I happened to look over and see this place on the way out. Pizza was awesome, the cook... and the cashier guy were so nice & friendly. We will definitely stop by again and tell our friends & fam about this place. Read more
This place is hit or miss. One night you'll get a delicious pizza cooked just right. Another night, you'll get a burnt chewy... mess. We are pizza lovers and it would be great to make this our go to spot, but when you spend $75 on pizzas and they aredelivered burnt...that's just bad business to let food leave your restaurant that way. Read more
Update: the owner offered to replace the order the day we left the review. We finally managed to stop in for it months later... lol. The crew working was fantastic and took excellent care of us and gave us the replacement order which was fantastic. Iwould like to thank the owner for doing what he could to resolve the issue and for his fantastic crew for the delicious pizzaand garlic knots. We will definitely be returning soon!!! I honestly would love to give a better review but can’t till nypizzeria makes this right and we get to try it again, we have left both a voicemail and emailed them with no response. Verypoor customer service. We ordered 2 pizzas one Hawaiian and one cheese steak and garlic knots. The steak pizza was slightlyover cooked, had very little sauce, only a few pieces of steak and no other toppings as advertised. The Hawaiian was the betterof the two but was slightly over cooked, had very little sauce, and toppings were poorly distributed on the pizza. We orderedhalf a dozen garlic knots they were cold and only received 5 last time I checked half a dozen is still 6. Read more
We ordered boneless chicken wings, garlic knots, sausage pizza, and a sausage and pepperoni calzone. They didn't have any... marinara for the knots and calzone (we asked for pizza sauce in lieu of the marinara, which was fine, but it was cold), thecalzone top was burnt and the seam was raw, the wings were basically nuggets (although feet were delish), and the knots tastedreheated (not fresh out of the oven). The service was a "1"... no service-with-a-smile here. The only reason I didn't give it 2stars was that our companions who ordered the pizza said it was tasty and they would go back. I won't bother. Read more
first time trying this place out. so i ordered online and had it delivered. Knots Large NY Pizza with extra cheese $30 with... tip. Knots were not good at all, they were terrible. no flavoring, nor did they taste good. threw them away actually. Pizza onthe other hand was very good. Perfect sauce to cheese ratio (very important), i will say i wish it was cooked a little longerbut overall solid. I would try this place again. Read more
Pizza was awful. The crust was completely raw and disgusting. Sauce tasted like it came out of a jar from the grocery store.... Honestly tasted like a cheap frozen pizza. I have no idea how you can charge these prices with this kind of quality of pizza.Never again. Read more
Once a week visit in the past 3 weeks, Great Flavor and friendly Staff. At first, we were just ordering different kinds of... pizzas, multiple slices, garlic bread with cheese, sometimes garlic knots and Chicken wings. Tonight's visit was not assatisfying as the last two weeks, we ordered an 18-inch BBQ pizza w/extra chicken. The toppings - sauce, cheese and paid extrachicken does NOT seemed adequate amount to cover an 18-inch pie. 2-inches of outside crust is a little too much crust. I wasexpecting the same coverage of toppings and consistency as we have had from the slices of pizzas from previous visits. Fullymelted cheese on the garlic bread would have been a plus. Read more
Place was clean with nice vibes but the pie was lackluster and failed to reach the appeal of authentic New York Pizza! I would... give this place another try when. I wouldn't go put of my way to try a slice! Read more