Reviews for Papa's Pizza in Mount Joy, PA
Had cheese steaks tonight. They were good tasting but there was very little meat in the bun. Most places I?m stuffed if I eat a... whole steak but tonight I could eat more. For your high price you must put more meat into the sandwich. In the future I?ll eatat some of the other pizza places in town where I get a good tasting steak sandwich that?s a normal good size sandwich. Read more
Great customer service. Delivery & the food was both on point, and cannot complain at all. Great sauces & consistency! Keep up... the great work, will be ordering again. Read more
So we had people 6 people over and got pizza. We ordered 2 large pizzas. 1 with extra cheese and extra sauce, which I was... charged for. None of us 6 could tell which was the extra sauce with extra cheese. Both pizzas looked the same. I get chargingfor extra toppings but it would be good to actually get them. 6 people can?t all be wrong. I did not call at that point I couldcareless I live 15min from this place. The pizza was very good and taste like the old papa pizza The girl at the front counterwas soft spoken but very nice. I could tell she was newer but did a nice job. We will be back as this was the best pizza aroundbut I will be asking next time since I always order extra cheese and extra sauce Thanks Read more
I ordered a mushroom and pepperoni pizza well done and a cheese steak tonight for pickup. The wait was 35 minutes. When I got... there the pizza wasn't even in yet because they were having printer issues. I was upset at first but they rushed my order andboth were Very Good!!! Sorry you all were struggling tonight but thank you for doing all you could to fix the issue!!!! Read more
For starters we LOVED the old Pappas our go to pizza place. Now for the NEW Papas...... a huge plus is the food was very hot. We... dined in and waited almost 45 minutes for 2 items. Another 10 after that for the forgotten fries. Very very unorganized and wayto many young employees on their phones and having boyfriends there. They were very friendly and I do realize it may be a bitdifferent for them. They need to buckle down and it could really be a great place for them. We will go try again. Read more
I was so happy to see Papa's open again on Main Street in Mount Joy. I have ordered lunch to go a couple times since then, and... been very pleased both times. The person answering the phone was friendly and helpful, and once I was in the shop I was servedquickly. The price for their small sub lunch special is so reasonable, and it's always more food that I can finish. Love Papa's! Read more
I've ordered hundreds of pizzas from here for events, as well as quite a few subs. They are punctual for scheduled orders, and... the staff is friendly and helpful. The food is always delicious! I'm never disappointed. Seating inside is fairly limited but ithas never been crowded when I've been here. Love this place. Read more
Pizza was great when the reopened. Now it ok. I really wish they would clean the dining room. Lots of flys even in the winter.