Reviews for Amato's Wood Fire Pizza Italian Restaurant in Mount Joy, PA

I had a great first experience here. I got the chicken Alfredo. The sauce was good and the portion size was good. Even had some... to eat the next day. My grandmother got the chicken parmigiana which was delicious as well. The only thing that they needed wasmore sauce. My family has always liked a lot of sauce. We also had a voucher from local flavor where you spend $15 and get $30.So completely worth it. Read more

Our first visit and overall it was a great experience. The food and service was excellent!

This place was AMAZING. Met a friend here for lunch a few days ago and we got so much food and I don't have a single complaint... about any of the food we got for us and 4 kids. Everything tasted phenomenal. Super hot and fresh, very tasty. Had a wonderfulserver who was on top of it in every way. Place wasn't dead but also wasn't crazy busy where we had to wait on our food for along time. Only took all 6 of our meals about 10 Min to come out to us. Will Def be returning again and again Read more

We finally got around to trying out Amato's. We got their wood-fired pizzas (yes it's a real wood-fired oven...not gas) and we... were REALLY impressed. To us, the pizzas were comparable to LUCA in Lancaster City (seriously). I cannot speak to the rest oftheir menu, but as far as the pizzas go...we'll be back! Read more

I tried their new Pucce sandwiches and they are spectacular. It's fresh handmade bread for the sandwich cooked in the brick... oven. Prices are slightly higher than your usual pizza joint (paid $12 for a sandwich instead of $9 at other places). But thequality and flavors of the food are totally worth it. Read more

Three of us ordered 2 gourmet pizza pies. The star is a Stella pizza- it was amazing, so many topings that melded well... together. The arugula pizza is the other picture and again, plenty of toppings. Our waitress was very pleasant and the foodand drinks arrived quickly. I highly recommend Amato's in mount Joy! Read more

The food is great, my Chicken Fajita Wrap was delicious. My husband really enjoyed his Cheesesteak. Ready to go back and try... some other delicious item. Wonderful servers. Thank you. The meatballs were a sub, but I usually order hot subs with no roll.They were delicious. 2/22/21 Tried the Puccie Salentina, so delicious. My husband had the very good Chicken Cheesesteak. Foodalways great. Thank you. 12/24/21 Back again, had a no bun burger with their great fries.. Husband had his favorite,cheesesteak. 1/21/22 Tomato soup and salad, so good. Pasta with delicious sauce and yummy meatballs. Read more

Amato's was excellent! Our expectations were definitely exceeded- from the food as well as the service and atmosphere. Everyone... in my party enjoyed their meals and the menu had a large number of unique options at reasonable prices. We'll be back sometimesoon! Read more