Reviews for Horseshoe Tavern in Morristown, NJ
Great place to party, drink, and get rowdy. The staff could be better about maintaining the ladies restroom. I got there at 12... on a Sunday and the toilet paper was out in one stall, meaning they didn't fill it up the night before, or the morning beforethey opened, and it was still empty at 3pm. They didn't fill it up between 12 and 3 because I kept checking that stall. Ifinally asked my friend to speak to the manager about it since he knows him. It would be ok if there were a lot of stalls, butthere are only 3 total, which is not enough when it gets busy, which it was. Unrelated to this specific experience, on Saturdaynights it would be nice if they had a female staff member in the bathroom to prevent multiple girls going into individual stallsto do cocaine. Read more
Bartender/server was exceptional helping provide for the kids. DJ for giants games. Take that how you will
Came here for sunday football around 12:30pm. Just wanted to grab some apps, drinks and watch the game. I would rate the food a... 2.5 - the pretzel was big but it was burnt on the outside so we didn't finish it. The mozzarella sticks were good, but they'repretty hard to mess up, and the buffalo wings were average. There's definitely places in Morristown with better wings. Serviceis a 3 - we stood at the podium for about 5 minutes before we were told we could seat ourselves. With Covid, I thought theywould prefer to seat people to social distance accordingly. It took a long time to order drinks and even longer to order food.We debated going up the bar to order food there since the waitress wasn't coming over to the table. I would return to only drinkand watch the game, not to order food. I would also order 2 drinks at a time to offset the long wait times. Read more
7/22 Update: Went here in July since I had a good experience earlier in the year and unfortunately it was a totally different... experience. Service was super slow and the food wasn't as good. There were 2 bartenders, 1 of them randomly taking shots anddisappearing for periods of time. At one point we were ready to order but we didn't see our server for 15 minutes, then he justwalked in the front door. No idea why he just left for a while. the female bartender was doing an ok job but was justoverwhelmed while the male bartender ran around drinking and taking breaks (apparently). Eventually we had waited so long fromwhen we wanted to order dinner that by the time our bartender finally came back around we just asked for the check and left. Iunderstand the difficulties in staffing right now, but they weren't so busy that 2 bartenders couldn't have handled it, theyjust seemed lazy and disorganized. 1/22 Review: Exactly what you want from a local sports bar. Quick service, modest beerselection and good pub food. Read more
I give them a 5 for Value and quality of Food. Great value for happy hour. The chicken wings were the best I've had, nice tender... meat, the dry rub was great. Had the cowboy steak twice and very good, although thinner cut, price is worth it. 6 people in ourparty, had cowboy steak, Drunken chicken, Ruben sandwiches, Ribs. Everyone loved their meals. I have be here twice and will begoing back. Read more
Great bar. Good food and drinks. Really loved the flat bread.
Nice size bar, clean and food was pretty good. had wings and the big pretzel. open air bar with awesome live music by Wayne Lyle... and Ben Clapp (didn?t catch the guitarists name, sorry) Read more
Really cozy bar/restaurant experience. Great alcohol selection and food was GOOD (not just "bar good"). Will definitely be back!