Reviews for Gario's Pizza Villa in Montgomery, IL
was such a treat to go eat at my boyfriends favorite pizza place from when he was a teenager. we came up from Florida and... enjoyed your place 2 x !! hope you keep 1 or 2 of the old wooden booths for nostalgia. Thanks ???? and sooo delicious ???? keepup the good work ???? Read more
Rude person on the phone. Put me on "hold" and just put the phone down. For the next five minutes I heard the f word about 13... times. I had to call back. They said they don't deliver to orchard and 30, even though when I attempt to order to my store forlunch ON THE CORNER OF ORCHARD AND 30 they tell me I'm "out of their range." I asked if they could cross the street. Got put onhold and it was just a "sorry." Class acts these people. Read more
Gario's is a place that family and medium size groups can have pizza, salads and drinks in a fun atmosphere. The pizza is... undeniably the draw! It is very good. When I was looking in the kitchen, however, it was a bit lacking in gleamingness. They aremore interested in getting the pizzas out then grabbing a broom to sweep up. Try Gario's Pizza, you will like it. Read more
The restaurant was very clean. You place your order at the counter and they will call your name when ready. We had the sausage... pizza and Italian Beefs and were happy with our choices. We visit Gario's from out of state and always look forward to stoppingin!! Read more
I want to love Gario’s, but Lord forbid I happen to order during their busy hours. Seems like they simply can’t handle the... work load and the quality always suffers. Ordered a pizza with pepperoni, bacon, and hot peppers (their way of saying jalapeñopeppers), and not only did I have to wait over 25 minutes past the pickup time but they took it upon themselves to put sportpeppers on the pizza. If I wanted sport peppers, I would have asked for them, but I guess Gario’s just knows what’s best forme. So, if you want a pizza that is late and with toppings that you didn’t want, go ahead and order from Gario’s duringtheir busy hours. It might still be good. Otherwise, steer clear. Read more
We've been going to Garios for 20 years. The atmosphere is comfortable and the food is good. They are a must-stop for the... locals. Pizza is thin and crispy, sliced pub style with decent options for toppings. They also have beer and soda on tap. Thereare games for the kids and a large fireplace in the center for cold nights. This is a good spot for birthday parties or familyget-togethers. The pizza is tasty and hot. My advice is keep the ambiance and rustic interior that gives folks that comfortablefeeling but add some adventure to your pizza offerings. Be bold and step out of the comfort zone. Your pizza skills are there.Lets see some Garios-only authentic creations. The bones are there, they have the skills, and if they add some unique flare tothe menu it will take it over the top! My Local guides score would be 3.75. Read more
The pizza here is pretty decent, everything was cooked properly and tasted good. They have some really yummy Mac and cheese... appetizers that I'd recommend. Staff is alright, they didn't seem like the friendliest of people, but they helped out when wehad questions. The interior was clean and the place was nice to hangout in. They do have a small selection of bottled beer aswell. My only complaint with the place was their marinera sauce for the pizza. It tasted like a bland tomatoes sauce and itoverpowered everything else on our pizza. Not sure what they use but I did not like that. Read more
Quality family owned thin crust pizza. They have the bears game on every TV.