Reviews for Tomatinos Pizza and Bake Shop in Montgomery, AL
NTCC Foodie Friday Small Group enjoyed another fun night of yummy food at this local pizza restaurant. Fresh ingredients made... for delicious pizza. We were pleasantly surprised with the selection of baked goods for sale! The wait staff were very friendlyand attentive (even though they were slammed with huge take out orders) Thanks for a great night out - once again! - NewTestament Christian Center Foodie Friday Groupies! Read more
The calzone is so very good. Kitchen could pay closer attention to ingredients requested. They left off a couple items from my... friends pizza. Read more
Josh was super helpful and friendly. The restaurant is very spacious and well decorated. The bakery offerings were really good.... The Margarita pizza was great though not exactly Italian, I think of it as Alabama Italian. And the focaccia sandwich was hugewith meatballs. Super great local place, food and service! Read more
Nice little pizza shop. Their pizza is pretty good. Their parking is also sufficient given the area. I did try their Greek salad... and will not order again. I grew up on Greek salads in NY! and this wasn't what I remembered. Read more
I just wanted to leave a review of how awesome our dinner was tonight. We drove 15 minutes from our hotel to pick up pizzas and... then ordered their blueberry/white chocolate bread pudding. It was delicious! We love finding local pizzas vs. chain places, andthe added dessert was a bonus! It was definitely worth the drive. The beautiful homes were also nice to see. Thank you forsharing your culinary expertise with a great community. I wish we could have sat outside and enjoyed the ambiance as well, butwe had to get back to the hotel. Sent from my iPhone Read more
The interior has a rather stark, industrial-looking interior but the food is good. We had house salads which had lettuce,... olives, cheese, tomato, and white onion. The orange vinaigrette dressing is excellent. The pizza's crust is crispy and nottough. The toppings are generous. I rated it four stars because the service was spotty. Our server disappeared for long periodsand then would suddenly reappear when the other server started to wait on us. Read more
Wonderful pizza with a side of acceptable service. I have been a fan of this place longer than a decade and since I first... started going the service had usually been good but never great. The pizza however has always been excellent (though in myopinion it doesn't travel or reheat well). In it's new location it lacks the hole in the wall charm it used to have but kept theart. I would recommend trying it and forming your own opinion and ignoring what constitutes mine. Read more
Delicious pizza! Service a little slow and we were not checked on during meal. We had to find server to get our check. Our go... to pizza place and will definitely return. Read more