Reviews for Westlake Fish House in Montauk, NY
I have always loved coming here but my most recent experience was very upsetting. The bartender was very rude. Made my sister... feel very uncomfortable and we ended up having to leave the restaurant. Very disappointed and upset to have this experiencehere. Read more
Some of the absolute best sushi I've ever had. Prices are a bit on the steep side, but hey, it's Montauk! Our bartender Liana... was wonderful. Read more
We leave our boat in montauk And we have a fur child, the owner James was so amazing to our baby girl (It was her 12 bday)... English bulldog! The food and drinks were perfect? such a great atmosphere ! We will Be back again next summer! Read more
Westlake is even better than its interesting menu might let on. Every dish was a delight. I don't know what they put in the... broth their mussels are steamed in, but I could have easily drank it down like water - it was EXCELLENT. The grilled shishedopeppers were a standout appetizer, and the sushi was so fresh that if you threw it back in the water it might have swam away.The linguine with clam sauce was just right, and even would have satisfied my Italian dad, and the steamers (a family favorite)were super-fresh, and - bonus points - very well cleaned. Major kudos to the kitchen staff here: there was not a single speck ofsand in a HUGE serving, which is seldom the case in even the fanciest of restaurants. I wish I could remember more of what Isampled, because the four of us shared everything, and not one flavor missed the mark; each dish I tried was better than thelast. The atmosphere and staff were very welcoming, and the surroundings are quite comfortable, as well as very clean andwell-kept. Despite our arriving a bit close to the end of service on an end-of-season Saturday, we were treated with care andattention. Not once were we made to feel rushed or hurried. Though I'm sure the staff wanted to get home, we were treated in afriendly, relaxed, and attentive manner. My family has eaten in almost every restaurant that has opened up shop in Montauk forabout 40 years now, and many greats amd not-so-greats have come and gone, but after our first meal there, Westlake is now at thetop of our list. We left satisfied, happy with our experience, and determined to come back soon - and often! Read more
The food is absolutely incredible, the restaurant/marina gets beautiful sunset views, the bar has such a fun vibe, and the staff... is the sweetest and most attentive. I crave West Lake daily! The tuna tiradito, pepper tuna, shishito peppers, and sushi are todie for! Read more
Sushi tasted precut and tuna was a bit dried out. Calamari was soggy and left a puddle of oil on the bottom. This place most... likely gave me the runs ruining two days of vacation. Read more
Great food and live music. Live music was a bit too loud, forcing us shout across tables. My linguini clams is one of best... I've ever had. It's not cream based so the whole fish was light and enjoyable. Fried calamari is tasty and crispy. Sushi waswell made and presented. Read more
We?ve been there twice on Saturday during Labor Day weekend for lunch and small bite and drinks in the evening. Food during... lunch wasn?t great and came with hefty price tag. Real disappointment was in the evening. Staff was extremely rude and had badattitude especially waiter working bar at the back. Not planning to go back. Read more