Reviews for Harvest on Fort Pond in Montauk, NY
When you're in town its the place to be. Probably the best restaurant in MTK. They are usually open 7 days a week.Off season... closed Mondays. Food is always consistent, seasonal, seasoned, service is great. It gets really busy, during the summer there isa line of people down the parking lot 20 minutes before they open. Make a reservation in advance or get there early for barseats. Note it is family style and portions are actually huge so go with a group or order accordingly. In the off season theyoffer half portions which is epic so you get to enjoy more things off the menu. Swordfish piccata, grilled oysters, seared tunaare some of our favorites. They got blue cheese olives too for martinis. Bread is awesome, it comes with butter and shreddedcheese which is strange but its their thing and you have to embrace it. They have $25 bottles of wine too. Incredible views ofthe sunset, koi fish in the pond, outdoor seating. Thank you. See you soon. Read more
Tell 'em Barsnobs sent ya! Amazing place. Family style service and plates. Big plates of food. Delicious and fresh. A casual... spot near the Montauk Pond, right in town. Really nice service and a beautiful setting as the sun sets. Drinks were delicious aswell. A real nice experience, a definite stop while in Montauk. Bring the family since the food will be shared. Read more
Such a lovely place in Montauk. The menu is family style so be mindful of this when ordering. Everything was so delicious!
A nice restaurant in Montauk. A friend recommended this place and it didn?t disappoint. We had the Clam pizza and the... Orecchiette with sausage and broccoli rabe and it was very delicious! Nice atmosphere and vibe and great service as well. Read more
Exquisite food. The pork tenderloin with the Apple chutney was the standout for me. The sweet chutney paired excellently with... the salty pork. The steak was excellently cooked and salted. The calamari salad was well dressed. I do not know what the dessertwas because some friendly ladies from the next table shared it with us, the fruit and ice cream combination was very refreshing.All 4 of us were very happy with our meals here. There is a very nice outdoor seating area next to the lake with a pier leadinginto the lake. Read more
TLDR; High end prices, okay food, poor service. Don?t recommend. Went here for our 10th year anniversary, was really looking... forward to it, and was incredibly disappointed. This restaurant just doesn?t make the cut for what it tries to be. The food wasjust okay, service was poor. I went to give back my fork I used for a Buffalo mozzarella with balsamic vinaigrette and was toldto keep it for my chicken parm. Not sure what ?high end? or expensive Italian restaurant wants you to mix your balsamic forkwith marina, but I assure you it?s not good. Not to mention, when they messed up our order the server was incredibly rude aboutreplacing it and then aggressively dropped on the table. I can?t tell if they are just priced as a high end restaurant or theyare actually trying to be one, but for those prices and poor service I cannot recommend. Read more
It's been many years since we've had dinner here. We forgot how good it really is! Best is the family style portions. Had the... lamb ribs, the striped bass, and the fried calamari salad. Read more
We had dinner here twice during our Pre Turkey Day trip to the Hamptons (Amagansett).. The Red Snapper [flash fried then baked]... my wife had was awesome & huge.. I had the Blackfish also great.. Read more