Reviews for The Crow's Nest in Montauk, NY
I dream of Lobster pasta all day every day. And if I could have Crows Nest every night for dinner, I would! It?s a truly magical... experience. I love the ricotta that is fluffy perfection, and the interior design, views, sunsets make me want to pull out mycamera and take photos each and every time. Ugh now after writing this, I?m craving their pasta but it?s 10am. There are firepits, multi level bars, picnic tables, and the best fairy lights to add a whimsical element! Read more
Crow?s nest the best place I?ve ever been. Service was excellent, she was always asking if everything was ok, if we need more... water or another drink. food was perfectly cook and drinks were Perfect as well. we got a table outside with a beautiful viewand a nice weather. I couldn?t ask for more. The best experience I?m definitely coming back soon. Read more
My experience here was just alright. Let me say that I am vegetarian so did not try much of their menu. I ordered the wild... mushrooms and dandelion pesto pasta. The mushrooms were fine, can?t say much about them. The pasta was not very good and had aburning after taste. However, the ambiance of this place was very nice. They have both indoor and outdoor seating on a largelawn that opens up to the water. Read more
One star only for nice waitress, waiting table abou 1.5-2 hours, be ready for this. there was about 7-8 empty tables outside, we... came to celebrate my wife's birthday, and ask to sit outside, I even gave 20$ for this, but they still sit us in noisy insideplace, which is pretty usual and not very nice, tables so close to each other. Food is usual mediterian and too overpriced weleft about 500$ for 4 people and ordered just 2 chicken 2 fish and 2 deserts. That's nice tables what you can see on picture itis just as advertising campaign, they will never sit you there, even if you ask then 3 or 4 times, even if you pay for it andespecially if it will be only 2 of you, it will be empty all the time. Very disappointed ???? Read more
Loved everything about this place. Menu was amazing, appetizers and main dishes were excellent. Wine, cocktails, and kid drinks... were really good. We loved walking about, maze for the kids, little pop-up bars, and more though-out the property. Read more
Expectations vs reality. Noisy , crowded place. I came here with my family to celebrate my bday. I was very disappointed. To... sit with a beautiful view at their iconic tables with canopy, you need a miracle. (almost all of these tables were free duringour visit) They will most likely give you a table inside where people sit super close to each other, with no view. This placehas nothing to do with their social media image. Not worth the money if you came for the vibe. Read more
The service is good and quick. The food was also good but overpriced. Also we didn't get to sit outdoor on empty tables(even... after request). Even when we wanted to enjoy the atmosphere and nature, We were forced to sit inside a crowded and noisy area.Although the food quality n taste is good, not sure if I will be willing to overpay especially when I can't dine in the(available) ambience of my choice. Read more
Went in for dinner on Friday night. We sat outside. The restaurant was very busy, I understand that, maybe short staffed too,... but I don?t believe it is enough of an excuse for the way our server interacted with us. Asked for drinks, I ordered a glass ofwine, but my guests weren?t ready, the server just turned around and walked away? I later flagged her down to order, and laterto add something to our order, but other than that, we never saw her. No interaction with us other than to just take our order.No one checked if the food was to our liking, and this is where the main issue came. My pasta was good, but my guests, who weresharing a pasta did not like theirs, at all, they barely touched it. The server came to ask if we were finished, we were, shetook the whole plate of pasta and didn?t think to ask why we didn?t eat it? Or if the pasta was ok maybe we were full? Nothing.My guests were embarrassed to say anything, so we just asked for check and left. We were hoping our experience was going to bebetter, we do hope to come another time, but our first experience was not nice. Read more