Reviews for Hilltop At Montauk Manor in Montauk, NY
We had an excellent meal at the Hilltop last evening. Rockefeller stuffed mushrooms were amazing. Fish was fresh, beautifully... presented and deliciously prepared. Staff was friendly and helpful.it was our first visit. We will definitely be back. Read more
The Manager made us feel very uncomfortable. I stayed there for 3 nights and it was the same scenario each time. She would... attend to our table last. It was really an unpleasant experience. The food was fine. Read more
Beautiful place! However it?s run by your sober church aunt. Way to many rules and usage of the property could be so much more... with a bit charm from management. Restaurant was lit like a school cafeteria at night with big bright coca-cola glass fridges.Visiting the bar felt like you where but put in the corner to be ashamed. Pool closes way to early. Every staff I met was niceand agreed with us so it must come from management/coop. Read more
A true find in Montauk Ambiance, food, service 5 star. Our waitress katalina also a treasure. Garden seating quaint and... peaceful. Read more
This place was awesome! Great food. Stand out was the octopus and the mushroom appetizers. I had the burger and it was not... overcooked with plenty of toppings. Perfect location too. Nice sunset. This is high on a hill over looking the bay. Thegrounds really add to its unique location. Perfect with kids as they have a lot of manicured lawns to run around on while youeat. Read more
Mushroom appetizer ?to share? was delicious, but consisted of five tiny mushrooms, crab chowder tasted like oregano slop, fish... dishes were bland. Prices were way too high to leave hungry. Read more
Waitress is lovely. Butternut squash is Awful ????. It was thin and tasted like Celery soup!! The Chicken Parmigiana wasn?t any... better. Staff was cleaning the windows with a strong scented cleaner, while I was eating!! Something terribly wrong here? Read more
My birthday dinner last night was a pork oasis buco and amazing desserts?Just as special as my visit to Montauk a year ago.... Colleen will take care of you! 11 months ago: I had dinner, but they also have breakfast and lunch, and you have choices ofrooms and ambiance. The moment you drive up to Montauk Manor expect something extraordinary. Don?t miss the scallops! Read more