Reviews for SmallPie in Milwaukee, WI
Went here with my daughter and granddog. Outdoor patio was lovely with its surrounding pollinator garden. We shared a pepper... chicken wrap and veggie small pie. Both were tasty. For dessert we had a slice of coconut lime pie..yum! This place is petfriendly with complimentary dog biscuits and ice water outside. Sidewalk chalk also available if you feel artistic. They alsoserve wine and beer I believe...as well as fruit drinks..smoothies...soft drinks. Was a good experience and we'll go back again. Read more
One of our favorite places in Milwaukee! We always stop by when we're in town because they have, hands-down, the best key lime... pie I've ever tasted. All the flavors are perfectly balanced and their crust is spectacular! We've also grabbed their sandwichoptions on occasion and have been very satisfied with each one we've chosen. Definitely looking forward to our next visit. Read more
This place is awesome! Tried the veggie Alfredo handpie (amazing Italian spiced filling and flakey crust) the turkey pepper melt... (they did not skimp on the sauce!) The coconut key lime pie (whipped cream was homemade, I could tell), and the door countycherry limeade. Love that their ingredients are seasonal and from Wisconsin, and the outdoor seating was a perk! Loved the viewof the butterfly garden and the dog treat jar...my dog loved it too. Hope more places like this pop up! Read more
SmallPie always delivers a fantastic assortment of choices and outstanding quality. The patio is a great space to enjoy a... morning coffee and a great slice of pie. It's been a pleasure seeing this business grow and thrive and I look forward topatronizing it for years to come. Read more
Cute location on a quiet corner with a walk up window and plenty of outdoor seating. Delicious savory hand pies (we had the... sausage hashbrowns and the Cuban pork) and fruit pie (peach). The coffee is a great blend paired with the flaky pie crust. Read more
Don't get me wrong, the food was very tasty but I didn't get everything I ordered. I asked and was charged for bacon and pickles... with my sandwich but didn't receive either. I was really looking forward to trying there handmade pickles and was verydisappointed when I didn't get them. I also asked for no spinach on the other sandwich I ordered but they put spinach on itstill. Keep making great tasty food but maybe pay closer attention to the actual order. Read more
Delicious pies with amazing customer service!! PIES: Their dessert pies are so creamy and rich yet not too sweet. Perfect... sweetness and flavoring. I also enjoyed their savory pies. Highly recommend their chicken herb pie! STAFF: I visited this placewith my husband for his birthday. I called to confirm their store hours and they were very pleasant to talk to. Then they calledme back to let me know their store hours had changed (because their air conditioner broke). I thought that was very thoughtfuland kind of them. They also gave us an extra pie when they accidentally dropped the last piece of the pie we ordered. Haha Read more
I've tried all of their cream pies. A little pricey but they give you a pretty large slice. They use to have a punch card... where you could get a free slice eventually but they stopped that so I guess its even more expensive. The pies were good andhad unique flavors but the pies that have a plain white cream are not sweet enough. If you just taste the white cream it'salmost like they don't add any sugar. Another annoyance is when I get pie to-go. They seem to be very sloppy when getting aclean slice out into a container. Almost everytime, it looks like a mess. One time, they even gave me the wrong flavor. Read more