Reviews for Mike's Mr. Pizza in Milton, WI
Best place for pizza delivery around. How they fold the crust is ????. Stay away from the bread sticks. They are basically just... flat dough that's hard and that a pizza cutter can barley go through it..hyper bland. Cheese curds are legit and chicken stripstoo. Drivers are friendly and usually very quick. Longest delivery has been an hour, fastest was 25, averaging about 40, whichis fine because I'm 17 miles out. If you make them drive that far, make sure tip at least 5 bucks. Read more
In an Airbnb in Newell on the rock river, 9 miles away and these folks gladly delivered a fantastic Gyro Pizza??????????. Don?t... second guess this place, topnotch !!! Read more
My family and I order all the time, absolutely our favorite pizza!!!
I am used to having very good thin crust and deep dish pizza since I live in Chicago. I therefore did not expect much when I... randomly ordered from Mr Mike?s while on a recent visit to Wisconsin. I was pleasantly surprised how tasty and flavorful theirpizza is. Prices are very reasonable too. Read more
Just had Mike's Mr. Pizza for the first time and that will be our go to. I was blown away getting an awesome pizza and gyro at... the same place. Keep up the good work! Read more
Over a 1,000 bucks in two yrs delivered. Seven times called about no extra cheese. When I called last week. The woman on the... phone said that the owner made it. If that?s extra cheese and pepperoni im sorry Read more
First time ordering from this local establishment. They have nailed pizza! We ordered the Full Nelson. Crust was perfect and... held up with all the meat. Sauce was like nothing I?ve tasted, but how I?ve always imagined?perfect!! Toppings were tasty andplentiful. We live on the out skirts of Milton and are thrilled they will deliver to us. Our new go to! Try them, you won?tregret it?.until you eat the whole pizza, because it?s that delicious! Ou Read more
Pretty good Wisconsin hometown pizza. Their Thursday special is a steal if you're a toppings fiend. Heavy on the cheese with... crust that's a bit doughy. If you're into that heavy cheese style this could be a great place for you, but I personally wishthere was more crisp to the crust.(tried both regular and thin) The real high points of this place to me are their burgers andgyros. Thick burgers for a reasonable price with good topping choices and a great bun. Gyros are just solid all around withquality not-from-a-package meat and decent tzatziki. Read more