Reviews for Your Pie Pizza in Milton, GA
my little brother and i have been going to yourpie, especially on fridays after school, for around 3 years now. after the... service i experienced today, i am not sure if i will ever come back to this location. i was recently diagnosed with celiac andhave to completely conform to a gluten free diet and it has been extremely difficult. i expressed that it was frustrating that ihave to pay extra for a disease that i can not control. the person at register was very disrespectful and after we took our seatshe went to some other works and said disrespectful things abt me. once i got my pizza, it looked like it had been manhandledand was cold. not only was the service poor, but all the tables were filthy. as a customer, i should not have to clean the wherei am abt to sit. i used to work at this location and know for a fact that it is expected that every table is cleaned immediatelyafter someone leaves. i am very disappointed by my experience and so is my brother. Read more
National pizza day so where do you go? Your Pie of course. Packed but extremely fast service, super nice staff that didn?t seem... flustered by the large Thursday night crowd, and did I mention fast? From order to hot out of the pizza oven in minutes. Highlyrecommended! Read more
Good place for a quick pizza dinner. They had an option for whole wheat base, and u can make your own pie. Cost of 2 customized... pies came to less than $20. Read more
We are not big on chain restaurants but this certainly doesn?t feel like one and is probably because of how fresh and done in... front of your eyes everything is! The pizzas are delicious and the fact you can create them makes it that much better! Sidesalads leave some to wish for but this is a pizza place anyways! Get creative and make your pie! Next time we will give thegelato a try too! I?d certainly recommend this place if you haven?t! You may just get kind of hooked when does pizza cravingshit! Read more
This was my first time trying Your Pie and it lived up to all of the reviews that I read. We tried the wheat crust and gluten... free crust and both tasted great. The toppings are all fresh and was good! The sauces on the pizzas were yummy, so put all ofthem together the pizza was incredible! Then you add a beer and gelato for dessert, you have a fantastic dinner! I'm alreadyplanning my next pizza! Oh, the pizzas are personal size pizzas. Read more
Wow! Best lunch I've had in a very very long time. We have four kids and finding a place after church that is quick enough so... that we can get home for naps has always been a challenge. We often compromise quality for speed. Your pie has it all; awesomequality- the peach pie was as good as a gourmet pizza joint- and the food was soo fast it came out before we could get allseated!!!! Highly recommend. Kinda hope it doesn't become too popular so we can keep coming. But something this nice deservespraise! Read more
Everything about this place from the building to the decor to the creating and ordering process to the staff was top notch.... Unfortunately, the food did not live up to what the rest of the experience seemed to promise. Various types of flame firedpizzas have always been my favorites, mostly because the way the cooking process along with the thin crust usually brings thebest out of the pizza. The pizza here was simply unremarkable. The toppings were good but the sauce and crust were almostflavorless. And, it's true the sauce makes the pizza. Nothing bad to say, just nothing positive. However, due to the overallpleasurable experience, I will give the place another try. An establishment focused this much on providing excellent servicedeserves a second chance. Everyone can have an off day. Update: went back the next day and as I hoped, it was much better.They were just super busy on Pi day. I will add Your Pie to the lunch rotation. Read more
Stopped by after dinner for my free birthday treat! One of the many perks of being a rewards member. You get a brownie ???? and... choice of 2 scoops of gelato ????I tried butterfinger, wow that was amazing!!! Thanks - Your Pie Pizza ???? Read more