Reviews for John's of Arthur Ave. in Milford, PA
Very yummy food! We got their menu in the mail and figured we would give it a shot. Pizza is nicely thin crust; but not too... thin. The garlic knots have amazing flavor and homemade! It's not that big inside but it's definitely homey like with thefireplace. Definitely going to go back! Read more
Food is good if you want to wait 2hrs for delivery and cold food! Then you call and they say new driver and the customer should... understand 2hrs and cold... Joey's is way better... our last johns order. Read more
So honestly best pizza place in Milford for delivery. Pizza has gotten so much better lately, it?s great! I order at least one... time a week. Some of the other appetizers and stuff could use some work but man the pizza has gotten really good lately,whatever you guys are doing for the pizza, keep it up! Read more
We have ordered many times from John's, food is usually good. However we arrived 40 minutes before closing and we're told... "kitchen closes in 5 minutes". We ordered a few simple menu items, paid and waited until 10 minutes after closing... For theworst food. Our pizza was trash, the sandwiches were gross and the salad had (not listed on the menu) an inedible amount ofpowdered, cheap cheese. The tiramisu was FROZEN. I truly believe that the owners should send in secret shoppers to see howchaotic, unorganized and sloppy the place is the hour prior to closing, because no one there cared about customer service, justcounting tips, rolling up mats and being rude. Too expensive for mediocrity. Read more
Hands down best pizza in the tri-state area, I grew up in milford strictly as a Joey's pizza kid but man I have not been back... since trying John's, never been disappointed. The graffiti pizza is my all time favorite and their desserts are also amazingespecially their toasted almond cake 100% reccomend!! Read more
It?s a sad day for me. Their grandma pie was amazing. But alas, it?s no longer square and the crust is not as good. I?ll try... other things but it?s very disappointing since it was the only thing we really love on the menu. Hopefully they?ll bring itback. Read more
Excellent pizza. Exceptional crust, excellent cheese and sauce, quality toppings. The only thing holding it back from being... perfect was it was a bit too greasy. They do have a great selection of pies though. Better than any place by me in Sussex. Read more
This is an excellent pizza place that I've ordered from several times. They also have a loyalty program that you can sign up... for, which lets you keep track of your purchases and get discounts as you go. They also have weekly specials to get pies at areal reasonable price. I recommend using these! The staff is extremely friendly, and the atmosphere inside is definitely nicefor your typical pizza place. Outdoor seating is a nice touch for the warmer months. This is the best pizza in this section ofPA that I've tried so far. I recommend! Read more