Reviews for Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop in Midland, TX

I was down from California visiting a friend and he took me here. We decided it was a cheat day and grabbed a 6 pie... sampler..... Lets just say it was delicious! Pies are good! I wish we had places like this in California! Texas has all the goodstuff! :) Read more

I needed several appreciation gifts and these Pies were well received! The hardest decision was choosing which pies to purchase.... ** SUGGESTION ** If you need Christmas ???? gifts for teachers, coaches, baby sitters,... Consider the Buttermilk Pie Shop.They have a special that?s hard to resist. ********** 12 Yummy MINI Pies for $42 *********** Read more

The Shop was clean and the staff was very attentive and nice. The Coconut Cream Pie was not very good. The crust was over a 1/4"... thick on the bottom and not baked very well. The filling was very sweet. Sorry. Read more

Really good pies, staff is great polite and helpful. New to the area and considering this is the only pie shop within the miles... on each side they do a really good job. Love the southern custard pie, the apple and blueberry are my next favorite. Willdefinitely try other flavors as I see my self going there quiet often. Took off one star because the pies are some times seemlike undercooked for my taste. Nothing to worry tho I put them in the oven for 10 minutes and they are upto my liking. Nothinglacks on the flavor tho. Recommend it. Read more

I wish I could give 10 stars. The pies are always amazing and the service is fantastic! I completely forgot to pick up some pies... that I pre-ordered for thanksgiving. They were gracious enough to stay open a few extra minutes for me to pick them up. I ordertheir pies for every big holiday and work parties and we are never disappointed!! Read more

The first couple times that I bought pies from here for work functions, they were amazing. The apple, peanut butter, and oreo... pies are some of the best I've ever had. I was excited to serve their pies when I hosted Christmas last year, but when I triedto order they said that they were only offering a very select few flavors of pies for the holiday, none of which I had triedbefore. I was disappointed but went ahead and ordered a few based on how much I liked their others. I don't recall the flavors Iwas forced into, but I was extremely disappointed by them and embarrassed that those were the only desserts I had to offer myguests. I haven't been back since. Read more

My dad came to visit from Washington state and my husband and I told him about this place and he was so excited to try it out.... We failed to check their business hours before heading over after dinner and got there 20 minutes too late. They saw us andactually opened the doors and let us in and were so humble and so kind to serve us. We've had several of their pies in the pastbecause my husband's boss orders from them all the time. The buttermilk pie is my favorite. It's delicious. My husband reallyenjoys the pecan pie as well. Great pies and great people! Read more

Stopped by today and picked up a coconut cream and chocolate pecan pie. Hands-down the best pie I have ever had in my life! I... guess some might consider them a little pricey, but you get what you pay for. I?ll be going back for sure :-) Read more