Reviews for Yani's Pizza in Middletown, NY
The food is amazing but the customer service isn?t they will try and jip you a dollar or two if you give them the chance
Ordered through DoorDash came almost 2 hrs late and food was cold. Never received our soda and when store was called we were... hung up on. Very unprofessional. Read more
The pizza is decent. I got the wings in their ?yani sauce? and it is straight vile. I?ve never seen my wife make the face she... did when I had her taste it. Loaded fries weren?t the best either. The wings tanked the review for me though. I feel ripped offfor paying for them. Read more
Ordered a chicken parm combo with fried oreos tonight. Placed the order well before 9:00 they close at 10:00 . I placed it... through doordash. I called once said my order was on it's way. It is now 10:20 PM as I write this review and my order stillhasn't arrived. If I could leave 0 stars I would. I would definitely be reporting this to doordash and also calling for a refundtomorrow once Yani's is opened . Read more
Delicious pizza, one of the best I've had living in NY my entire life! Awesome sauce! And best fried dough!! Can't believe I... missed this hidden gem for so long.. must try!!! Read more
This is hands down the best pizza In Middletown NY. THE Marinara is so delicious, I always order large size. Everyone that... works at Yanni are super nice. I highly recommend there boneless wings 5 ?????. Read more
I get lunch from here quite frequently if they arrive to open the pizzaria before lunch is over, most times they aren't open... before 2. I like their paninis and their wings are really good quality. The Pizza is hit or miss (at least the times I have hadit. I like a crisp sturdy crust with some chew to it (more gluten!) I have gotten decent slices and I have gotten floppy andwet slices. The customer service is really good, they are always friendly. I just wish they would be consistent in theiropening hours. I would probably have lunch more often but like I said above, they aren't usually opened according to what thehours posted online say. Read more
Pizza good with red sauce most of the time but you need to make the bacon chicken and ranch a lil tastier. ????