Reviews for Pellegrino & Son's Pizzeria in Middletown, NY
Ordered the "Blackened Steak Salad". Very disappointed. The meat is over seasoned with taco seasoning! Taco seasoning! Also,... iceberg lettuce, really? Read more
First time here and it surely had a lot of choices for slice pizza. Food was good. Service was normal. A simple place to grab a... meal. Read more
Tried the Tuesday Night special which included a large pizza and the appetizer sampler. Everything was delicious. Pizza crust... was flavorful and had the perfect amount of sauce and cheese. Mozzarella sticks and onion rings were tasty as well. There aredaily specials which all are good deals to feed a family. Definitely one of the better pizza restaurants in Middletown. Read more
I asked for two slices to go. The pizza had burnt bubbles. There were three slices. I asked them to cut into another pie. She... said I can?t. The owner did nothing to help. I will never come here again. Read more
been there many many times, always clean. friendly staff. I ordered my custom Pizza. Great taste ????????????????????????.... highly recommend. ohh chicken wings mmmmmm... Read more
I just ordered this grandma pie (04-30- 2022)for dinner, me and my husband are very happy . This is our very first time trying a... grandma pie and the flavors that Pellegrino & Son's use for this pie is simply chef's kiss. We will definitely be ordering fromthis restaurant more often. The delivery guy was also very nice . The best in middletown and our pizza was just warm but thatwas not an issue because it tastes amazing. The picture that I posted about the look of the pizza has nothing to do with thequality of the taste of the pizza I posted the picture because I was excited about trying this particular pizza for the firsttime ???????? Pellegrino & Son's is a definite must try you won't be disappointed!!! Read more
Today was my first time there. Over the top amazing. I had the Penne alla Vodka pizza, and a chicken bacon ranch OMFG the Penne... alla Vodka slice was to die for. I am sorry that I have not been to this place sooner keep up the good work guys very very cleanand you could see right into the kitchen love it love it love it I can't wait to come back I will be ordering on Saturday. Thankyou to my friend Tony from the laundromat for telling me about this place. My dad and I combined had four slices and two drinksthe bill was under $16 wowza love it love it love it. Read more
Food was good but pricey. Not exactly in our neighborhood but the flavors don't disappoint.