Reviews for Americana Diner in Middletown, NY
Excellent staff. Delicious food. Ample parking. Cleanliness of premises. Friendly staff. Kids friendly. Reasonable rates. Our go... to place of choice when in town. Love Americana and Highly recommended. Read more
I ordered a club sandwich and it was HUGE. No way I could eat it all, I started picking at the meat and bypassing the bread. The... French Fries were especially good and tasty, nicely crisp but fluffy on the inside. Read more
Shake was good, service was good, and you should note that a bunch of the options that say they're only available on cerain days... may be ordered at any time if you opt out of hollandaise sauce. Why they dont always have hollandaise sauce (or poached eggs??)is odd but not my place to ask. Good enough. Read more
Picked a random place to eat while driving to NYC. Definitely a no frills diner, but meal I orders (the Greek platter with... seafood Bisque) was pretty tasty. Milkshake was meh at best. Would go back here the Greek platter. Read more
So far has not disappointed us. This is our go-to dinner. They have everything we crave and it's delicious!
This diner was a nice size. They were able to accommodate 10 of us. The staff was very friendly and professional. The prices are... reasonable and portions were a large size. Everyone took home a doggy bag. I had the Cajun burger and I was eagerly expecting alot of robust flavor. I was disappointed because it had a hint of Cajun flavor and it wasn't bursting with flavor in a trueCajun style. It wasn't bad, but there as a lot of room for improvement. Also I asked for my burger to be cooked medium and itwas medium well. The size of the burger was a nice large size. My nephew's burger was cooked medium when he asked for mediumwell. I took a bite out of my son's Cuban panini. The flavor was good but it was on the dry side. Everyone else said their foodwas good. I would give this diner a 3 and a half stars if it were available. Read more
Very good. Best Matzo ball soup I know of! Overall a nice friendly place. I had never been here until the last year or so. My... wife told me how much she loved it, so we finally got there and never disappointed since. I can't give 5 stars, even though manythings were worth 5 stars. But like most dinners in my humble opinion, I feel sometimes they try and do so many items that someare just "OK". Never had a BAD meal though. All the staples are great, burgers, breakfasts, gyro's, soups. Read more
Great old school diner! Our waitress was very pleasant and attentive. The food for the most part was very good. Generous... portions, for sure. I had meatloaf, mashed potatoes and corn. It also came with a soup or salad. I chose chicken orzo soup. The soup was very delicious and tasted homemade. It was very savory?-I wish there was more??. The meatloaf was good but alittle dry. It was served with some nice brown gravy that tasted like it had nutmeg in it. It was good, but unusual. Themashed potatoes were homemade and not instant. My picky son gobbled them up! What my son didn?t eat was his own dinner, whichwas the kid?s Mac and cheese. It looked good, but when I tasted it (since he didn?t like it) I found it to be very bland. Itwas elbows mixed with a ?Cheese flavored? sauce. I say that it quotes because the only thing that made it mimic cheese was theorange color. It wasn?t awful, but it also had no flavor. ???? I got plenty of potatoes and corn so I just shared my food withhim?it?s all good. He also had French fries. They were pretty standard and he enjoyed those. My husband loved his pancakesand sausage?.he left not a speck on the plate! ???? Overall a nice experience, and next time we are in the area we would loveto come back. I saw some sandwiches being delivered to another table that looked great. I think I will try something like thatnext. ???? Read more