Reviews for New Monmouth Diner in Middletown Township, NJ

ONE and DONE!!!!! My over all rating is < 1 Star. Service: .5. Unfriendly waitress and inattentive. We sat down and she took... our drink, but we waited about ten minutes to bring our coffee. Was not good at answering our questions about the menu. Feltrushed the whole time. Was pleasant to us when we asked for the check. Quality of Food: .5 brought my wife?s food and broughtmine about 5 minutes later. I ordered 2 eggs and home fries. The food was cold and the potatoes must have been sitting on thegrill for a while. They were hard and nasty. My wife got the Rancho Huevos skillet with Chorizo, there wasn?t even a quarter ofthe sausage in the dish and it had no flavor Atmosphere: 1 It?s a diner so it was normal and the place was full. There was kidsin the booth behind us and they kept kicking it. Not a fan of misbehaving children. Cleanliness: .75 The place was over allclean enough, but the bathrooms were not very clean and there were no towels to dry our hands. Needless to say we will not bevisiting this diner again. Read more

Excellent atmosphere old school 50s style with a ton of awsome photos , collectibles and memorabilia , awesome friendly staff... our server Brittany was very attentive even though it was very busy. Outstanding food served in a timely manner. Large portions. Amazing desert selection . Love this establishment. I had the baked Mac an cheese with bacon it was absolutely delicious. Amust visit if you are in the area . Highly recommended. Read more

The diner is very unique looking on the exterior and interior. You'll find your typical diner food here so there is something... for everyone. The food tasted great, our waitress was excellent and the rest of the staff was friendly. The place was very cleanboth in the restaurant and the bathrooms. I definitely recommend stopping in. Read more

This place has great food and a great selection of food. The owner consistently greets guests at the door and is well aware of... how his operation is being run. Both of the meals we ate were delicious and cooked well. I look forward to eating here again. Read more

Came here to get a bite to eat before going to the hockey arena. SO much to choose from - almost too much! There is something on... the menu for everyone! Would recommend and would go to again! Read more

The place is quite warm and welcoming, but I was a bit disappointed at the sheer number of people walking around without a mask.... I ordered the eggs benedict with ham, and really enjoyed it. It was savory and satisfying, and would recommend it. I tasted theveggie omelette from my aunt's and found it a bit flavorless. I really like the waffle that my cousin got though. The fruitsthat my cousin ordered had a funky flavor to them though, I don't think they were the most fresh, so I wouldn't recommendordering them. Read more

Wonderful diner! A fantastic example of the classic New Jersey diner. Good, fresh food. Reasonable prices. Quick & friendly... service! This visit, we ordered 5 different appetizers to share as a table, and everything was amazing! Read more

Typical Jersey diner with a large menu. Went for Sunday breakfast and it was busy. Our meals came out quick, portions are big,... and the food was good. Would go back, especially to try one of their burgers from the large burger section. Read more