Reviews for Papa Murphy's | Take 'N' Bake Pizza in Middleton, WI

Ordered cowboy pizza not enough cheese or sauce very dry.

Great pizza, sides, and desserts. Very reasonable pricing. The order ahead for pickup option is awesome. You just walk in find... your order on the rack and be on your way. Read more

Friendly and very helpful staff! After I got my pizza the staff came out and jump started my car! Really got me out of a jam... couldn?t say enough positives about this location! Read more

Super easy online ordering and contactless pick-up. (You walk in and grab your order from a rack). Pizza is tasty and they... have Halloween and Valentine's day pizzas that the kids love. Never had a problem with an order and the people here are alwayssuper friendly and helpful. Read more

Incredible establishment. Truly, there is no end to the positive remarks I could leave...but alas, you and I have lives to get... back to and probably can?t spare 45 minutes each. So I?ll keep it short. Oh Papa Murphy?s, you have done it again. Writing lovestories left and right. Grilled chicken and sun dried tomatoes? Swoon. But tonight, a different love story was written. Myfriend and I enter the shop, give the pleasant staff our order, and sit down and wait. Enter Mr. Hunkypants. Dressed to thenines, beautiful eyes and eyebrows (all that was revealed due to the mask requirement, but all that was needed to be seen)...theword that comes to mind is ~suave.~ I nudge my friend, who has taken an interest in this young man. ?Odds you ask for hisnumber?? ?Oh, I?ll talk to him!? she responds. Surely the warm atmosphere, kind staff, pleasant aromas, and captivating wallphrases encouraged this response. Well, this confidence held true as, on our way out, she chats with him a little bit,compliments him, and then we leave. The adrenaline rush was already high, but then, as we?re trapped in the car by another carbehind us, waiting to leave, the dashing young man walks out. He drops off his pizza in his car and walks up to the drivers sidewindow of our car. After two minutes, numbers were exchanged and hormones were running. We roll up the window and scream. Allin all, fantastic, heartwarming experience at Papa Murphy?s tonight. Richard if you see this, text my girl, she?s waiting. Andshe?s a gem. You couldn?t do better. Papa Murphy?s, if you see this, please like this or comment if you will pay for thewedding. 2020 has been rough, but Papa Murphy?s is going above and beyond to facilitate a few moments we all need. Pizza was asexpected. Read more

Best deal on Tuesdays. $10 Large Pizzas. Gotta love it! So easy to bake in your own oven. Comes with great instructions. ... Just tried the pan pizza for the first time. It was great too. Read more

One of the better Papa Murphy's in the area. Always courteous and the pizzas are made to perfection.

I've picked up many pizzas here, & I've never been disappointed. All ingredients are fresh & in generous portions. Sometimes... I'm only waiting a couple minutes before my pizza is ready, & they still apologize for the wait! It's all good. Read more