Reviews for Dickey's Barbecue Pit in Middleton, WI
We used to order from here all the time, but the portions we?re getting are getting smaller and smaller. We couldn?t believe the... tiny to-go boxes that arrived to us today. The side salad is no bigger than the size of a mason jar lid and there was less thana cup of each meat in the two meat plate. Almost $20 for less than a cup meat is crazy. Read more
One word: delicious. Dining room design is appealing and the staff were great. We share a couple dishes and were given extra... plates upon request. Read more
My first time here but it won't be my last!!! The food was EXCELLANT and the staff made me feel like I was part of the family. ... I ordered takeout but the atmosphere here is inviting and beckons you to stay and eat here. I also found the prices to be veryreasonable. I will be back!! Read more
This review is for the catering from Dickey's BBQ at this location. I HIGHLY recommend the catering from here. Dickey's... catered our wedding for nearly 100 guests at an outdoor reception, and the food turned out incredible. Honestly, so much betterthan any catered food I've ever had. Everyone was blown away, and commented on how great the food tasted. Catering can be veryhard, including keeping the foods at the right textures and temperatures. But Dickey's nailed it. The staff were incrediblykind as well, and helped to clear dishes even. The catering manager, Ryan Prentiss, was amazing from the start. He did awonderful job booking our reservation and menu choices, as well as executing the set up and delivery day-of. I would absolutelygo with Dickey's again for any future catering needs. It was a highlight of our wedding. Thank you! Read more
The staff here came through for me in a pinch one night at 8:30 pm! I was responsible for bringing the meat to a night shift... going away party and Dickey's had EVERYTHING that I ordered! My coworkers raved about the marinated chicken, the tender porkribs, the equally tender chopped brisket, the cornbread (went faster than free food stamps! Lol) and the creamed spinach! Theywere quick and reliable! They gained new customers at my job with their delicious food! Read more
Bunch of clowns.. dry brisket, smashed+burnt bun.. fries were soggy garbage.. membrane on the brisket was 1/3 of the entire... sandwich. Whoever worked, cooked, or oversaw this food being made like this on Wednesday 12/22/21 (at night) should be loadedinto a spaceship and fired into the sun ? You couldn?t pay me to order food from this place ever again. I would literallydecline free money, free food, and/or both. That?s how bad my food was.. especially for the price of it all. This Dickey?slocation has lost my respect and quite possibly my business forever. Read more
AI just ordered a $12 bbq meal but paid about $18.50 in the end for delivery a few blocks away. I was starving, working late and... it is like 7:30pm at night so I'm tired. I get my Sandwiches on dry bread without bbq sauce. Didn't even get it on the side.What is the point of a bbq meal that gives you the choice to pick bbq and then you get none. I am sure it is good but thebrisket meat and dry bread are hard to eat. It is unfortunate I had to waste a review on this incident Read more
Just got my door dash order... Spent 20 bucks on a plate.. ordered the turkey and burnt ends... Got pulled pork and literally 3... 2 inch by 2 inch pieces of turkey... No dressing for the salad. Not worth it for the price.. Read more