Reviews for Biaggi's Ristorante Italiano in Middleton, WI

Biaggi’s has a large wine menu. The bacon wrapped dates are a tasty app! The entree was decent, salmon and artichokes in a... lemon sauce. Overall good meal but everything was a little cold when served which is why 4/5 stars given. Read more

Better than olive garden. I wasn’t expecting that much since it seemed like a typical Italian place that wasn’t actually... Italian (Ahem- olive garden). However, inside the place was very cozy and looked upscale. The prices are pretty high, $20.However, the food is actually pretty good. Not authentic Italian in the least, it’s very American, but some people like that.Overall might go back! Read more

Didn’t expect much, but to our surprise we were pretty amazed at the quality of food for a chain restaurant! The ambience was... incredible, our waiter Michael was very attentive, overall the food was decent with huge portions! The best part was theincredible focaccia bread which they make it in house. Read more

I really liked the inside of this restaurant as it is very classy and just looks fancy inside. The employees were also very kind... and helpful while we were there. I ordered the rigatoni bolognese and it was good. However I would say the best part was thebread with cheese and oil. It was very flavorful and the only thing I would’ve liked more is if they heated the bread upbeforehand. I think the prices are fair but the pasta itself wasn’t something spectacular. Read more

We really enjoy Biaggi’s. The food is great, service professional and served quickly. We did I have a small issue with the... crabcakes being too salty but that’s uncommon and they were polite enough to take it off the order. Read more

Went to Biaggi’s on a Saturday after graduation. We arrived around 3pm and they told us it was going to be an hour wait. Came... back after an hour and they told us it was going to be another 60-90 minutes even though the tables were still empty. Everythingwas reserved. They did eventually sit us down and majority of the tables were still empty by the time we finished. Theyweren’t very organized. Besides that, the food was not bad. We ordered the crab cakes, stuffed mushrooms, the lobster pasta,the short rib ravioli, seafood pasta, & salmon pasta. It was all good, but my least faves out of that list are the crab cakesand the lobster pasta Read more

Food was absolutely fantastic and very fresh! We absolutely loved the bread, and the stuffed mushrooms were amazing. We also had... the sangria (really good, not too sweet) and mojito. Bob was really knowledgeable and recommended some great options while beingso kind with amazing service! Highly recommend this place. Read more

They’ve got the best Brûlée in town! You’ve got to try it! !! One of the best Italian Restaurants in Madison. The Lobster... Soup is very tasty and filled with stuff, which is way over valued comparing to its price. The crab cake is very nice with orwithout the sauce. Green is very fresh! Pasta sauce is just the amount. The Cajun clover bright up the taste of thesausage. Didn’t get a chance to try the others. I ordered too much. All looks very nice and amazing. Read more