Reviews for Carlo's Pizza in Middle Village, NY
I went to Carlo's Pizza for the first time and had a awesome experience. I ordered a cheese pizza and a spinach calzone. They... normally don't offer spinach calzone but they made it special on a busy Saturday night. The cook with the glasses [sorry Ididn't get his name], extremely customer focused, stop.to tell me he made it special. It was one of the best I ever had, andthe pie was perfect. Carlo's pizza has a new regular customer. Thank you, to the staff at this fine establishment. Went backtonight, the spinach calzone was again excellent, but was happily surprised by the great tasting soup. Wife a little under theweather, so we ordered chix noodles. ... never thought a pizza place could make such a hearty soup. Thank you guys again!!! Read more
This is a very friendly neighborhood pizza shop. The guy in there are sarcastic and hilarious, the food is really good. The... pizza was delicious Read more
My wife is from Middle Village and we visit this place every time we come to NYC. The Veal Parm Hero is one of my favorite... things on earth. I'm from Oregon and we have nothing like this. It's a must stop every time. Read more
My favorite pizza establishment hands down. This is the real deal. I wish they had a Carlo's in Vegas because all the pizza... places that I have been to are junk. I miss you guys! Read more
Average Pizza not a 4.6. They only had fresh regular pizza, all the other varieties were stale looking. They advertised coal... oven, the pizza I had was not. Read more
Great clean place with a friendly staff. This place has a great variety of Italian food that tastes amazing for a very good... price. I would highly recommend anyone to come here if they live Italian food. (I also recommend they?re rigatoni with vodkasauce; it?s just perfect) Read more
The best pizza in Middle Village. You won?t be disappointed! Our favorite is Arugula with prosciutto and fresh tomato and fresh... mozzarella!!!! Read more
This place is never crowded, which is great when you want to stop by for a quick bite. The pizza is really good. My husband... loves their chicken slices and I don't eat an upside down from anywhere else. Read more