Reviews for Middle Island Pizza in Middle Island, NY
Great service! Great pizza! The slices are so big and filling. I couldn't even finish one slice lol
Apologizing in advance for Karening out but I was asked twice if I wanted chicken on my salad to which I answered, ?no,? but got... charged for anyway which made the salad warm and soggy. Additionally, if I?m ordering a slice this is not what I?m asking for.It?s pizza. If a slice has a giant dried out cheeseless bubble in it just throw it away. Unsure about how the rest of you feelbut that does not exceed, let alone meet my standard. Usually the food is good. This was just straight up annoying. Read more
?Lisa - UPDATE? Excellent Service. In & out immediately, always. Nice Aye! He said, why all the pictures. I said, cause Your the... Best! - Lisa Lichelle ? ?Lisa - Friendly quick service. Nice staff. Efficient. In & out always. Nice Aye. I got to try theirpizza. - Lisa Lichelle ? Read more
The deep dish cheese pizza had more dough then cheese. I could cut the top off and get two for one. The wings; so let's just... pour some buffalo sauce on half cooked chicken. This place was great 5 years ago. Read more
This place is a hit or miss when it comes to the taste and freshness of the food. I gave one star because the customer services... is always horrible, but hay I?m a New Yorker it?s be expected right. However when it comes to this place making sure thecustomer is satisfied please don?t throw your money away here very overpriced as well as over rated. Food one star because it isedible don?t get me wrong. Read more
I've been going there for atleast 30 years and they have always had the best pizza I've ever had as well as real good subs and... desert plus it's family owned and operated and the family is awesome and local Read more
Best Philly cheesesteaks pizza ever???? Must try????
I've been getting pizza on my lunch break here for years! It never disappoints. Specialty slices are absolutely delicious! So... many to choose from. The pasta fagioli is really good! Read more