Reviews for Athens Diner in Middle Island, NY
French soup was salty... gyro was very good and the fries too. Staff was very friendly so that is a plus.
Fantastic dinner, fast service and very, very friendly staff. Will definitely be coming back again soon!!!
Excelente service , quick and clean. The best diner so far in this area. Come in and be welcomed like family. Even if what you... want isn't in the menu they'll whip it up for you. Read more
Cute personal diner. Seated quickly, service was good. Food was served hot, made sure you had coffee. Clean place, clean... restroom. Read more
I absolutely love this diner. I live locally and feel so lucky to have this diner nearby. The owners are two absolute GEMS; the... nicest, hardworking, honest, welcoming, and lovely people you could ever meet! You are welcomed at the door with a smile,checked on during your meal to see if everything is OK, which it always is! The food is OUTSTANDING, consistent, priced right,and exceptional with a "home cooked" feel. Be sure to try the homemade mashed potato's!!! I frequent this diner at least 2x perweek since it opened! Forget any other nearby diners, this one is the one to visit! Love them! Read more
Been coming here since opening and they never seem to fail and impress me with their delicious and fresh food! Tried this dish... today and it was super yummy! Definitely would recommend anytime- great staff and service as well! Gotta check it out when inthe area- 10/10 Read more
We were looking for something local since my wife started working close by as she can?t Take long & we wanted something I guess... between lunch and dinner but not too heavy We found Athens was right next door where we found more than what weexpected. Tatiana was really nice & really good service I asked her about a couple dishes she took her time to explain as wellas she could which she turned out helping me out picking my Dish since I was split from the stuffed chicken With feta & spinachfrom what I had. The food was really good I had the grilled chicken Marinated over rice the chicken was well done which was justhow I like it With chicken lemon soup. My wife on the other hand had the broiled flounder stuffed with crab meat Which was aswell as she likes it because she didn?t say much about it and she ate all the fish she had a Greek salad. I had a goodexperience we definitely go back and have/try something else and or different. Took pics of not sure if new times menu looksthe same but just in case. Read more
A nice Thanksgiving dinner, even if it was lukewarm. Cream of turkey soup looked good, but lacked flavor. Chicken lemon soup was... good. Read more