Reviews for Gelsosomo's Pizzeria in Michigan City, IN
Kelly was our server and she is TOP NOTCH!!! The Italian beef was out of this world as was the Popeye! Will DEFINITELY be back!
Superb pizza, but the girl on the phone was super rude. I asked for pineapple and ham, and pretty much got mocked because I... didn't call it "Hawaiian". When I did get taken off of being put on hold before my order the girl on the phone opened with"pick up or delivery" then instantly started loudly talking with someone in the background for a good 10-15 seconds then finallyallowing me to order. Read more
Went in for dinner last night. Greeted at the door with smiles and welcoming people. Our order was taken right away and the food... come out piping hot. We has the Sean Fries a sub and a medium meatlovers pizza. All were equally delightful Read more
Service a bit slow but all in all a good experience. It's a small place, but the servers should check on drinks a bit more... often. Had stuffed pizza, salad (Ranch was meh) fried mushrooms and Mozarella sticks and pasta. I'd definitely come back forpizza, but the prices are a bit high on them so I'd probably just get take out. Read more
At the Michigan City location...had the Buffalo and Garlic Parmesan wings plus a Pepperoni Pizza...food was Fantastic. Wings... were cooked just right and with lots of sauce & flavor. The pizza was so good...probably best crust I ever had with lots ofcheese. Read more
Ordered a keto pizza to see if it would effect my husband's blood sugar. First time ordering from here. We are very happy with... our order! Surprised to find out the crust is sausage. Definitely diabetic friendly. Small salad is a good size. We will beordering again. Read more
The pizza was pretty good as was the garlic bread and wings, service was great it was not busy.
Michigan City location... We Ordered buffalo bread and expected more than 4 small slices for $9.00. Two of the slices were... burnt. Read more