Reviews for New York's Upper Crust Pizza in Menifee, CA

Leilani was such a nice ???? she took my order immaculate .. I will be coming back soon and giving her much more than a tip next... time .... Read more

Pizza looked sloppy , I was being cussed at by the cook a little skinny white boy that didn?t know how to do his job and left a... nasty looking pizza . Uncooked my son got sick from it and I can?t believe they have such unprofessional staff here . That lilwhite boy cook shouldn?t have a job. Read more

The Managers were awesome....the Pizza is Bomb! We just moved here and they noticed we were Military ...so they gave us 2... discounts! Very nice to see that customer service still exists!!! 5 Stars ???? Read more

Food was just so meh. There is SO MUCH OIL all over to the point that it's making me queasy. The wings have no sauce so idk... maybe I just had too high of expectations. Pizza also had no sauce. Just very dry and oily at the same time. Won't be comingback service was lovely tho. Read more

As far as I remember the pizza is decent but this will be my last attempt to order from them. The last couple times it tried to... order i was told they are not taking any more orders. When I asked why, I was told that they legally have to shut off theirovens 30 minutes before closing. It was only 7:10 on a Saturday. I said wow you close early he said we close at 8pm. I've neverbeen told I cannot order food an hour before closing. Bad business practice imo. I'm a business owner myself and if that were mystore I would fire an employee that refused service to a paying customer so they could leave early. I'm off to town Square pizzain Temecula I guess. Bomb pies.. Read more

This place was very disappointing. The service was terrible, while ordering the lady behind the register had a attitude, and was... very rude. The pizza was bland, barely any cheese, or sauce. This pizza reminded me of a frozen pizza from the grocery store,but I think even the grocery store pizza would have tasted better than this. Definitely will not be returning. Don' t waist yourtime or money. Read more

The pizza here is disgusting the service was flavorless I was just driving threw expectations were high and just the biggest let... down. If you can choose a better option do it. #notNewYorkWORTHY Read more

Best pizza I have had in a long time! And I love pizza..my wife and brother in law tryed some of their sandwiches. And they... were good also. Seats outside and inside, great atmosphere all around. And friendly staff. So go check them out of you tired ofquick pizza and want to eat real hand made fresh n hot pizza out of a brick oven. Treat your family! Read more