Reviews for Stone Toad Bar & Grill in Menasha, WI
Excellent food! My wife, son, and I have recently started eating dinner here for a change, definitely love their patio.... You... can drink and smoke out there if you choose to. She absolutely loves the Ruben Sandwich, I love the burgers I must say. As weboth have 20+ years of restaurant experience, it is nice to go a clean establishment and actually get Excellent food and servicenow days. Our first time there, we went to play pool, but found out sadly they don't have them anymore, despite the pics ontheir page. All and all I definitely recommend, it's worth at least one visit. Read more
First batch of fish was BURNED BLACK! 2nd was better. Server never cleared the dirty dishes from our table. She spent most of... her time at the bar. We've had burgers here in the past & they were very good. Deep fryer oil is HOT, it only takes SECONDS forfrozen fish to cook. Needs some improvement. We'll come back for a burger sometime. Read more
Had two different soups recently from here and it was the best we've had around Fox Valley so far!!! (Pictured is Ham and... potato!) Read more
While most of us enjoyed our burgers there was one person who ordered a steak sandwich which they did not enjoy it, while all... the burgers had nice greasy buns the steak sandwich has a dry bun and in between a dry steak the only thing she really ate wasthe fry because of how the steak looked unappealing because of it also having no toppings. I'd say the rest of the food was goodbut just know to not get the steak sandwich if you expect more than what I described. Read more
The different types of foods were great. The staff was exceptional. I had Mexican food it was yummy ???? we will be back. I... was not so lnclined to eat in the building as it was dark inside, so we ate out on the patio. Read more
Food was pretty great, a nicely-sized menu of items to choose from, and I'd love to try it again sometime. For a larger group... outside the service was pretty great, though if you're going to be drinking a lot it's probably best to go inside and order yourdrinks there. Kind of put off from drinking at the bar since one of the bartenders was not friendly at all. We nicely askedquestions about ordering inside vs outside and the bartender literally scoffed at the question and stormed off and couldn't havemade it more obvious that she was irritated with us for some odd reason. Read more
This was a huge disappointment. Wouldn?t even give 1 star but that?s the only option. Half of one would be more accurate.... Starting with the unfriendly staff that wouldn?t even look at you. Burger was asked to be medium but was raw and not evenlycooked. French dip was a .59¢ pack of budding beef that wasn?t even separated to make it look like it was something better. Asked for side of ranch and waitress came to table and slammed it on the table and walked away. Really bad food. Didn?t eveneat half of it. Hope we don?t get sick. Never would go back. Read more
Had the beer battered perch. Nice sized portion for the half. The perch was delicious. Highly recommend the beer battered. It... added a citrus flavor and the batter was perfectly crispy. Our waitress was friendly and attentive. It was pretty loud, a littledifficult to communicate, but it was a Friday night. Read more