Reviews for Coletta's Italian Restaurant in Memphis, TN
Not recommend. Dingy and dirty place. I purchased a pizza; with pepperoni, sausage and green Chile. It was greasy, burnt on... bottom (not crispy crust) and soggy. I ate one slice. My wife had two. Pizza Hut would be better and I don?t like Pizza Huteither. The only reason I gave two stars is the hot wings were decent. Total bill; medium pizza with three toppings, 6 hotwings and two teas. $40.00 Read more
It is worth the wait. You can tell the pasta sauce is not a branded product from a supermarket. It is dark in colour, thick with... meat chunks. The pizza we had was overloaded with pepperoni and the thickness of the crust was just right. They also provide ajar of shredded cheese which you can use according to your preference. Read more
A staple when we visit Memphis. My husband MUST get his BBQ pizza. He once again enjoyed his personnel pie this trip. I had the... Alfredo with breaded chicken. The chicken was excellent, very crisp. The sauce could have used a little more seasoning for mytaste, but overall it was tasty. Read more
There s a haunted spaghetti in their front case so... Dont order from this location if you arent local. It s super old school... Memphis and they re doing the best they can. Some menu items are amazing and some are not this kitchen's specialty. I couldsurvive on their garlic bread. Simple things are better here than complicated items. Check your order if you get take out. Theyhave a good staff but they're small and get busy at popular times. The Bartlett location is probably better but they dont havea haunted spaghetti. They might should check a few expiration dates on things like the black olives. Read more
If I could give them negative stars would. I ordered the lasagna, tortellini soup, and salad. The lasagna was spoiled and burnt!... I instantly had a stomach ache after my first bite and threw up right afterwards. The soup had 2 pieces of noodles and the saladwas all iceberg with 4 olives and 2 peppers and a little tomato (all of their pics are false advertisement). It was a horribleexperience and I?m never ordering from here again! Also, when I called the manager, she said the lasagna is supposed to be thatway (see pics) - I?m thinking no way it?s supposed to be spoiled and burnt. I wouldn?t recommend this restaurant to anyone! Andthey don?t hold themselves accountable and only make excuses. - the manager said she?s never heard that about their food and Ihighly doubt it. But that was that, she offered no apology or anything! Never again! Disgusting! Read more
the chicken parm is to die for!! The sauce is thick, meaty and packed with flavor. We torn through the raviolis before I could... get a picture. They make them fresh daily. The owner was there while we were dining and introduced himself, very personable & weenjoyed his stories he told us. I cannot wait to make our trip back! Read more
This place smelled like mildew. And didn't look to clean. It looks like it's been there for some years with no repairs or... upgrades. We were seated on the bar side. Which I didn't understand. Cause there was a much cleaner side with tables. The foodquality was horrible. I ordered lasagna and he ordered shrimp mushroom linguine. As you can see I don't know what that was. Butit wasn't lasagna. Was not good at all. She gave us To go plates and we took nothing. I gave star cause the drink we had wasgood which was sweet tea. Wasted $37 Read more
Food was great as well as service. It?s definitely a hole in the wall place but it?s been a part of the community for a while.... Everone should come try Colettas. Read more