Reviews for Medford Pastaria in Medford, NY
This place makes the best eggplant rollatini I ever had. Their pasta pesto is also excellent and their rainbow cookie cake is... super delicious. I love this place! This is one of my go-to restaurants, tied with just one other. Read more
Excellent food, very nice people, great specials, amazing pizza and delicious chicken dinners. We have been getting delivery's... from this restaurant for over 5 years now. One of the very first times i ordered was very late at night and the owner said thatit was too late for delivery but since i was on his way home he would happily bring my order-This was above and beyond and thisestablishment has consistently gone above and beyond thru the years especially during covid with their family dinner specialsand constantly helping the community.. Thank you to everyone at Medford Pasteria for all you do everyday and all the amazingfood you make. Read more
Was the most regular of regulars. We would eat there 3 nights a week (either take out or delivery). Tonight we made the decision... to give it a 6 month break after seriously considering if the food was so poorly made or something that was bad and would?vecaused food poisoning. I?m writing this review in the hopes someone takes it seriously. I have called and asked to speak tomanagers, and Mr Vitali (the owner) to just let them know what my experience as a regular has been and no one has responded. Iknow a lot have left (Ben, Amy, Manny, the attorney whose name I forget unfortunately no disrespect) but the quality of the foodhas suffered tremendously to the point of being inedible (just threw out my entire order). Most to go orders are wrong and wewon?t dine in because it?s lost its appeal. Hoping for change. Read more
Pasta night was great! It's $22 per person, includes a drink, salad, pasta, and dessert.
We recently went here for pasta night. It was our first time and we'll definitely be back! Everything tasted fresh and delicious... and the pasta was cooked to perfection. Very generous portions too. Staff were friendly and service was quick. The live singermade the whole experience even better! Read more
I don?t really write reviews but this is my first time ordering from this pizzeria. I place a doordash order for a pizza pie & a... tiramisu and as you can tell in the photo that the tiramisu had fungus. The pizza was amazing but when I called the pizzeriaabout my order. First of all, the lady who pick up was rude and it?s not even the fact that she was rude but when I explain toher my food had FUNGUS on it she said, ? well it just came out of the oven, & I just check the other ones and they look fine? soI told her, ? do you need me to send you a photo of my food,? which she then said, ?once again there all new.? And I worked infast food for 4 years so I said ?well maybe someone didn?t rotate them? & she said ?well we did.? Obviously not if my food hasfungus. Then hung up. Rude. Read more
Crew members were very friendly, polite and professional make me feel welcome.. food was delicious! Took a long time but we were... a party of 20 I guess is understandable. We will come back again Read more
Never had a bad meal out of here I go here often since it's pretty close..lil pricey but you get what you pay for..pizza is... always good and they do not cheap out on ingredients on the specialty pies. Pasta dishes are huge and always tasty Read more