Reviews for The Narrows Steakhouse in McCall, ID
The good: we shared the bison cowboy steak and bunch of sides and all were excellent. Our server was also outstanding. View from... the table was fabulous. The bad: waited 50 minutes to be seated?had a 8p reservation and weren?t seated till 850p and theytried to seat us in the back room with no windows while we could see 2 empty tables by the windows that simply needed to bebussed. Read more
Highly recommend!!! My husband and I stayed at the Shore Lodge for a couple nights after we got married and we decided to... splurge on this restaurant. We asked our waiter what he recommended, and he gave us some options and then said OR I could askyou a few questions and then just surprise you? whaaaat?! We chose that option and were not disappointed! I literally had thebest meat I?ve ever had. My filet mignon was cooked perfectly. They know what they?re doing there. It?s expensive, but for ahoneymoon getaway.. well worth it!! Oh also, if you get a steak they let you pick your own special knife that you get to use! Read more
Wow!! The Narrows blew my mind. The food was amazing, the ambiance and views were incredible and our server, Bart, was great. We... had a fantastic view and meal. I am so glad I found this restaurant. The French Onion Soup and Surf and Turf were out of thisworld. Highly recommended for that special occasion!! Read more
Great place for a romantic meal or getogether! Warm atmosphere with dim lighting. Great view over the lake. Really cool... retro table and chairs. Very well kept and clean! Then the service!! Forget his name, but he is an uncle and had his niecesbow on his tie. He was fabulous! Attentive, engaged in conversation, gave great suggestions....overall 10. It definitelyhelped that the food was an overall 10! Prime cuts of good steak! Sides and drinks were creative and delicious! We will beback every time we visit! Definitely worth the price! Thank you for a great night, especially after 5 prior nights and beingdisappointed by McCall restaurants! The Narrows in right on par with Aqua by El Goucho in Seattle and Masteoes Ocean Club inFt. Lauderdale. Those are my favorite places for fancy date! Read more
Had a birthday dinner here and we all enjoyed it. Steaks were cooked perfectly. I had a filet mignon which I also ordered along... with the truffle butter which came melted on top and the chimichurri sauce on the side. I put the chimichurri sauce across thetop in a nice thing layer once the butter melted and it might be the best steak I have ever had. The combo of the butter andsauce on a well cooked cut of steak was like eating candy. I honestly could not stop until it was gone. For appetizers beforethat, we has scallops and the Brussels sprouts. I think there was a balsamic glaze in the Brussels sprouts that gave it a uniquetaste. Scallops were large and well cooked. Sides with dinner we had truffle Mac and the asparagus. The truffle Mac wasn?t asgood as we have had at other places, but OK. Asparagus came with a poached egg and they were cooked just right. We had a coupleof cocktails to start and a few bottles of wine. Corkage is $20 a piece. The will not open a bottle of wine if it is on theirwine list. I was very surprised by the selection on the wine list. It is super extensive and has all of the big CA and WA redwines. We brought a Leonetti Sangiovese having not seen it else where, but they had it! Service was professional and consistentwith guidelines a Sommelier would learn. The other servers were quick to refill waters, bring replacement silverware etc.Everyone was polite, sociable and pleasant. They had a lot of different steak cuts which is great. No Waygu or anything, butmany large steak cuts. The Filet Mignon was 8oz and actually one of the cheapest steaks on the menu. Long story short, werecommend and will return when we come back to McCall. Read more
Wow! What a great meal. Quite pricey but a great dining experience. Service was prompt and friendly. Had a lake view table and... very nice waitress (is food server the correct term these days?). She was funny and pleasant. Steak was cooked to perfection andthe chef sent out small tasters between courses?a nice touch. Mashed potatoes were outstanding as was the wedge salad. Read more
If you find yourself in beautiful McCall Idaho, treat yourself to this place! Probably the most enjoyable meal I?ve ever sat... down to. Had the rib-eye, worth every penny. The lamb chops were on point! Our waiter Christopher was extremely knowledgeableabout wine and very friendly. Read more
Amazing food and service! Atmosphere was great and the overall main meals and sides were delicious!