Menu for Anchor Restaurant in McCall, ID

We went to the Yacht Club which has a great atmosphere pool and shuffleboard and a beautiful view of the lake. Anchors... Restaurant is upstairs which we did not eat there but I heard the food is good Read more

This was a letdown. We were wanting some good steaks for dinner, and decided against the Mill because of their negative... reviews. The only beef on the menu was prime rib, which we like, so my husband and I both ordered it. When it arrived the entireplate was drowning in weak Au Jus, and they smeared horseradish sauce on top of the meat. I detest horseradish, so I felt likemy beef was pretty much ruined. We've never seen prime rib presented that way. The mashed potatoes served with the meat (youdon't get the option of another side) were dry and salty. We sat outside and the view of the lake was lovely, but there was adrunk bride on the balcony of the bar upstairs shouting during the last half of our meal that someone should "buy her a shot fortrying the knot". Next time we are in MCall we will continue our search for a restaurant that will really wow us, and not chargea Benjamin for 2 cocktails, gluey potatoes and horseradish-slathered beef. Read more

Outstanding food. Negative ratings are incomprehensible to me. The three best meals we have eaten in McCall were here. Lamb... chops are superb. Salmon exquisite. Side dishes alone are worth the visit. If you want steak and potatoes look elsewhere: Thisis serious cuisine for folks who know the difference. Read more

The most underrated place in McCall. It?s tricky to find because it?s below the Yacht Club, but definitely worth your time when... you visit. It?s easily some of the best food in town and the prices are reasonable. Love their creative takes on some of theirdishes but if you?re also feeling less adventurous, tacos and fish n chips are available. Our waitress (wish I remembered hername!!!) was incredibly impressive. They were slammed and it appeared she was the only head staff there and she was crushing it.Attentive and giving every table the love they deserve but was quick and efficient. Truly some of the best serving skills I?veseen! She was brunette, maybe mid 30s?? If this sounds familiar give her a raise ASAP!!! Can?t wait to come back. Read more

Tired of burger joints and pizza restaurants in McCall? The anchor's menu never disappoints offering up super interesting fare... at a range of price points. Always delicious and well presented with a great view of the lake to boot! One of my favoritesMcCall eatery's. Read more