Reviews for Jay Henry's BBQ in McAlester, OK
It's a little food shack with a small covered seating area outside & customer-accessible bathroom. The food was great!
Terribly slow service. I ordered sliced brisket...(wasn't sliced, don't even offer it, she didn't even tell me) 11:15 an no... ribs no beans. Potatoe salad wasn't good, coleslaw not good. I'm giving 3 because bologna was good. If it wasn't I'd be givinga 1. Read more
We had a wonderful experience here!! I got pulled pork nachos. They came out laid out in a LG pizza box. It was 4x as much as I... could eat!! They were absolutely delicious. We will definitely be visiting again. Read more
Best kept secret is southeastern Oklahoma. The BBQ is amazing. The burgers are juicy as they come. Outdoor seating only but it... has shade and a restroom. Owned and operated by one of the nicest dude you will ever meet. Read more
Great BBQ. Good menu with some unique and tasty combinations. Haven?t had a bad meal here yet.
Beans were the best besides the lays chips. I had the widowmaket, huge sandwich but had no flavor. My friend had ribs and... brisket and they were flavorless as well. Nothing was fresh, the links were rubber like, bologna is not bbq (fried in askillet). Read more
This barbeque is fantastic. I eat here every time I visit McAlester and I can't wait to go back. Their Widowmaker is to die for!... The small restaurant has only outdoor seating, but if the weather permits, it's wonderful. The menu has something for everyoneand the loaded fries are incredible. Staff helped my friend pick something that suited her in a friendly way that showed howconfident and familiar they were with their food. Looking forward to my next visit. Read more
Order 3 burgers only got 2 went up there to get my money back for the one burger since they just closed they completely ignored... me while I tried to explain what happened Read more