Reviews for Papa Johns Pizza in Mayfield, KY
The pizza tasted like rubber. I asked for extra sauce and did not get it.
Poor service Pizza E T A was 38 minutes pizza arrived in 1 and a half hours we contacted the papa John?s location we?re lied... to about the pizza arrival time the employees were rude 1 employee even hung up on me the driver finally arrived glass eyed andstinking of pot This is definitely the guy I want driving around residential areas with children around Read more
Got one of the create your own papa bowl was awesome
I placed my order at 6:30 pm tonight for supper. It said the approximate wait time was 69 minutes. At 8:30 pm, I called the... store to ask I'd my order had been forgotten. He said that he was only driver, and I told him I understood. At that point hesaid, please understand that your pizza may be colder than expected, and it may still take a while to get. I waited another HOURbefore my order finally arrived, only for parts of the dough to still be dough. As stretchy as cheese. Gooey, and disgusting.Worst order ever Read more
I love this Papa John's location in particular. I've been ordering pizza from this location since they first opened up here in... the 90's. I've never had not one complaint that I can recall myself. They got great pies and always fresh! I recommend you giveit a try then decide for yourself. Read more
I was actually at the store next to the pizza shop when the owner came in and delivered them a couple of free pizzas, they were... giving pizzas away to the community after the tornado came through, the store next door said the owner had been present all weekdoing this, just awesome Read more
Ordered my pizza at around 5:20. Its now 7:15 and along with a large line of people that also ordered hours ago, I am waiting... for my pizza. This is not typical of papa johns so I dont understand what's going on. They are just making these pizzas it seemslike... what happened?? Read more
I love the Mayfield Papa Johns! The wait staff are really warm and professional and the food is ALWAYS delicious and hot whether... I pick up or they deliver. It's our favorite Friday meal night! Read more