Reviews for Michelangelo Pizzeria in Mattituck, NY
Mediocre food at high prices. You can literally Doordash from another local italian place , WITH tips AND FEES. And still... will be less than the price of this place. Read more
They Act like im robbing the place when placing an order. I will not go back again. This place robs you and makes you feel... like your the robber. Class a service! Read more
Made reservations for 6 for a Friday night at 6:45. Gave name to girl at restaurant entrance of restaurant part, she didn?t say... anything, just stood there, no attempt to help us. She just looked at me but that was it. I asked her about our table this timeshe mumbled something. After a bit I went to bar to inquire and was told they were working on it. Over an hour later and askingcouple more times they finally seated. Never got an apology. Our dinner was for 1 year birthday,, never even had dessert becausejust to late. had to bring baby out to car for a while because we waited so long. Called to speak to manager 3 times beforefinally getting a response 2 weeks later. They need someone who communicates better. Will never go back. Read more
Love their pizza here at Michelangelo's because it's so fresh, hot, and tasty! The service and staff are great and personable... and ready to make your experience and palate satisfying! I recommend Michelangelo Pizzeria. Read more
Amazing pizza, perfect sauce to cheese ratio. have to stop by if in the area
The Best pizza in town. Thin crust with the actual crunch when you bite into a savory slice. Yummy! ??????????
Awesome pizzeria, really cool interior atmosphere with cool pizza slice styles! Ranging from your standard Long Island cheese... slice (heavenly, perfectly greasy and juicy!) all the way to a greek salad slice, literally a pizza slice with a massive greeksalad piled on top. I had a great time, the guys running this place are awesome! We choose the right place to stop! Read more
Have eaten for the past 10+ years , Has changed ownership in that time . But Whoever is running this place in 2022 . ... Best of luck because you sure do need luck. Read more