Reviews for Mattitaco in Mattituck, NY
We went to the Wolffer Estate Wine Shop for live music and the Mattitaco truck. We did not get to experience much wine or live... music because it took Mattitaco 90 minutes to work through a 20-person line. Finally, when we got to the front of the line andgot our food, my wife and I found the tacos to be ok, not worth a 90-minute wait. That evening, both of us experienced thesymptoms of food poisoning either from our Bang Bang Shrimp, Carne Asada, or Lobster tacos. I shared this experience andrequested a refund from the owner Justin via Venmo and Instagram DM and he ignored me. Posting this review is a last resort as Irespect small businesses that are trying to grow, but when you ignore a case of food poisoning that your food caused, then Imust share. Read more
I was so excited to try this place after hearing other people rave about the food. Let me tell you, it did not disappoint!... Everything we ordered was so delicious and unique. I cannot wait to try other items from their menu. My only complaints are thatit?s a little confusing when you walk in. We weren?t sure where to go and the people working didn?t offer any assistance or seemtoo interested in what we, as customers, needed. Overall though, it was a good experience and I will absolutely be coming back.The high quality food more than made up for the lower quality service. Read more
I have long loved Mattitaco's food and have worked with them on a number of catering events in the past all of which I have been... thrilled by the results! My husband and I most recently hired Mattitaco to cater our wedding on June 5, 2021 and were once againblown away by the food! Everything was delicious and the staff was amazing, going far and beyond their job descriptions toensure every last detail the day off went beautifully! We worked with Justin to develop a custom menu featuring our favoritelocal seasonal produce, tacos, and large format seafood paella and an assortment of smoked meats. Joe the bar manager wasamazing and so communicative answering all of our questions and building custom cocktails for us based on our preferences.Everything was delicious and I can not count the number of guests who complimented us on the food and staff! Highly recommendfor any and all catering needs! Read more
Mattitaco was excellent! We were wandering around looking for something different, and came across this place. My wife and I... are crazy about tacos and this place nailed it. We had some BLT (Bacon, Lobster Taco), steak and melon, land and sea, Bahafish, and an Al pastor taco. These tacos combined with a pitcher of margaritas and one of their own Mexican Style Lagers wasthe perfect way to end our day! Great job Mattitaco! Read more
Amazing time here for lunch with my friends. the vibes were great, everyone was friendly. We had a small pitcher of margaritas... and loved that it was the perfect taste and not watered down! Food was yummy too, looking forward to coming back Read more
I wish I could make up a new word that describes the food and service from Mattitaco but I am not that clever so what I will say... is OUTSTANDING AMAZING OUT OF THIS WORLD! We were fortunate enough to have Justin himself come to our holiday party with thevintage airstream and serve us some amazing tacos and small bites. When you read about the "Dirty Fries" please know people arenot lying those things are SO Delicious. We cannot wait to hire them again in the summer and try all the other food that theymake. I strongly recommend you use them for your catering needs. Read more
This place is so good. Their tacos are delish and creative AF. I would have never thought of ordering or making a beet taco but... there it is and it was amazing. They also have a great selection of beers, some great local brews from Riverhead to pair withyour tacos. Read more
Best Tacos on Long Island! Birria...omg!!! So goood!