Reviews for Magic Fountain in Mattituck, NY
They're homemade ice cream is very good! Although if you're not on a trip out east it's definitely not some place that you'd... make a trip specifically for. It's just a nice bonus if you're already out east. Read more
Locally owned and operated. New & unique flavors added often. Even the fire department stops by for refreshing treats!
Kids love stopping here after a visit out on the North Fork. Great selection and a friendly staff!
Magic Fountain is the place to go for your Ice Cream fix. The choices of flavors are exhausting. It makes for a tough decision.... Especially when your only passing through once in a while. Do not let the long line deter you from getting your ice cream. It iswell worth the wait. The servers are competent and quick. So do not pass this establishment up when opportunity knocks.???????????????? Read more
Amazing ice cream! My favorites are rainbow cookie and mocha chip.
Drove by the area to get to the sunflower maze. Made a note of the crowd as we were passing by. On our way back, stopped here... for some delicious homemade ice cream - available in unique flavors, created and served with care. Growing up in India, RoohAfza was a summer staple - was pleasantly surprised to see it featured as a flavor (and on their banner)! Read more
Delicious and prices can't be beat! The summer sunset was amazing!!! Lots of flavors and they are great at listing what's in... each for dietary concerns and even have vegan options. Would love to come back next time I'm on the North Fork. Staff is alsofriendly and wonderful girls! Read more
whenever im on the north fork, i always come here. they have a great variety of flavors even for people who have a dairy... allergy. my favorite thing to get is the honey cinnamon ice cream with rainbow sprinkles and crunchies Read more