Reviews for CJ's American Grill in Mattituck, NY
Found this place on an outing out East with my friend. Delicious food with a laid back lunch atmosphere. Would definitely go... again when I'm out that way! Read more
The Yankee Potroast sandwich was amazing! So tender! Highly recommend. It was lunch so I ended up with the sandwich. Can't wait... to go back and get the dinner, OUTSTANDING! Read more
Such a great place! Lynn was our waiter and attended us with a high level of service. Especially having a table of 5 kids. She... was wonderful. Had coloring books and crayons for the kids. My food was also very delicious. Read more
Just had a wonderful lunch with my husband. The restaurant is immaculate and the staff is very friendly and attentive. The food... is delicious! I've been there several times and it never disappoints. Read more
Amazing food quality and presentation is always on point they never disappoint. Drinks are well presented . Our server is always... amazing very attentive making sure we are well taken care of . Worth the drive I recommended it ! ???????????????? Read more
Outstanding customer service,calm/family friendly atmosphere and great food.I ordered their classic burger w/bacon,fried egg and... cheddar cheese w/sweet potato fries. The owner was also very kind!I will most definitely return ! Read more
1st time visit & absolutely loved the place. A nice cab wine from Osprey Dominion to start. Then the manhattan clam chowder was... piping hot. The chop salad was seasoned perfectly. Then the rack of lamb was out of this world. The wait staff was very cordialand attentive. The management checked several times to make sure everthing was perfect. Now you see why I gaves this restaurant5 stars!!! Read more
Disappointing. Based on prior reviews we thought the food would be really good. The seafood bisque was extremely salty rendering... it nearly inedible. My Reuben sandwich was not too bad but my wife's grilled chicken sandwich was extremely bland. The saucethat came with the sweet potato fries tasted like it was made with pancake syrup and tasted weird. I can only recommend thetater tots I had plus the bread. Service was excellent. Read more