Reviews for Mr Gatti's Pizza in Martinsville, IN
The pizza was fine and the services fine. Don't come here. Expecting to play video games they have exactly two, the kids were... very disappointed. We will not be back. Read more
Firstly, everything else is 5 Star.. i am just livid about the carelessness.. Now, the Sub was on point.. Great food.. So, I... called ahead & left order.. I told them 3 times, had them write it down, " Do Not Put That Dang Puckle In the Box! " & Evenstated I'm Allergic.. Guess what, pickle in the box . Listen, it steams & condensates inside the box making everythinginside taste like pickle.. & leaves juice in the bottom.. Luckily i was there the second they were done & undone this HorriblePickle Fiasco before any real damage had been done to the awesome sub sandwich... Read more
This is a very sentimental place for me so maybe I rate it higher than other people would. The pizza is okay, buffet style, and... similar to what Cece's used to have. But what sets Gatti's apart for me is my childhood memories of a former location in myhometown. I remember the mini arcade and how my mom and I would go visit my aunt who worked there. My mom even had her babyshower for my little brother there. So many good memories. Those fond memories carry over to this location. The pizza isfamiliar and the place feels cozy. Read more
If you like pizza this is a good place to go. Lots of good pizza available of different kinds. Think they have pitchers of beer... available too. Good place to fill up. Read more
This place has amazing pizza! And the best part is the buffet! All you can eat! So many varieties of pizza that you just got to... try 'em all. Also, they have some awesome desserts like the Smores Pizza, Pudding Pizza, Apple Pie Pizza, and don't forget theIced Cinnamon Pizza! Brings back the memories of eating at the Bedford location, growing up. Closed for 10 years it seems, andeveryone misses it. BUT thank God for the one in Martinsville. Peace to all. ?? Read more
Mr. Gattis pizza has a flavor all its own. This restaurant has been here for 40 years! Not sue the original or first Mr. Gattis... location, but 40 years is pretty impressive. Parking was no issue, pretty large lot. Upon entering the establishment you payright off the bat. Get you cuts, find your seat and hit the salad/buffet bar! Restaurant was pretty clean, there was an employeecollecting the dirty plates so they were cleared off table pretty fast. I cannot complain about this location. The pizza andpasta were good as expected. Read more
Not very well kept, not super clean, very limited on pizza and pasta buffet. Salad bar was mediocre at best. $55 for 2 adults 2... kids! Wings were dried out regular wings with some hot sauce squirted on them... 5 out of 5 would NOT recommend. The young ladythat took our order was not very pleasant and had a chip on her shoulder. Unimpressed all the way around. Save your time &money! Read more
Enjoyed a great lunch with the hubby, son & mother in law . Food was hot , fresh & service was outstanding & the older waitress... was a doll & never let our plates stack up and even guided us on how to use this new icecream machine they have . It was topnotch service .. ?????? Read more