Reviews for Paesano's Pizza Spring Mills in Martinsburg, WV

I came in on the Wednesday night before Thanksgiving 2022. They were incredibly busy and appeared to be swamped with pizza... orders for this day which is very popular for dining out. They were extremely nice and efficient. It was promised in 15-20minutes and ready when I arrived. The pizza, stromboli and chicken tenders and fries were delicious and hot and fresh. Read more

Pizza was really good an the bread sticks were good wasn't expensive if I'm back here for work again ill def order from here

Last minute decision for a quick dinner and it was so delicious! We ordered delivery; the Works Steak and cheese sub and a... chicken, bacon w/pineapple calzone. We don?t usually do ?fast food? but the food here tasted homemade! My 4 year old (pickyeater) loved it too! Will definitely order from here again if we have pizza, calzone, or sub cravings! They also delivered soquickly, less than 30 mins. Read more

BE CAUTIOUS!!! Wish I could do no stars!!! We have eat here many times, up until tonight. This goes to the business so called... male manger! They messed up our pizza order and instead of the manager agreeing to make it right, we spent over 10 minutes onthe phone explaining how the mistake was there and we just wanted the correct pizza. Finally the owner agreed with me and sentout the correct pizza as long as we return the missed up one and we even told them we would tip the driver due to it not beinghis fault. 45 mins go by and the same so called manger showed up and told my husband next time when I call I should ordercorrected which was very rude and out of place. Due to the one EMPLOYEE that will be our last time at the so called pizza place Just be cautious if they mess up your order and you call nicely they will blame you and be super disrespectful. But the ladythat took my call was very kind and tried to be helpful. Read more

One of the best pizza and sub shops in the area ! You actually get nice portions, unlike other places where you get more bread... then meats ! Read more

Great food, great staff, great location. ????

Great Pizza and Fast prompt service. Do yourself a favor and get some good food.

VALUE!!! Decent subs, run-of-the-mill. Failed C.O.O.L. test. COUNTRY OF ORIGINAL LABELING. Their meat comes from Sam's Club.