Reviews for Montese's in Martinsburg, WV
My family and I went in to have dinner at 7 pm the salad bar was empty and we tried to request two pizzas to be made the man... made one then was we were told they were about to close and it was only 730 on the door it says they close at 9 .we will nevergo back again ???? Read more
1st time visiting last night & I love it! NY style pizza with all the custom flavor options. Tastes so much better than... competition like CiCi's. Will definitely be back again ???? Read more
I used to come her all the time but recently I visited again and expected a great experience like I used to. I'm sad to say it... wasn't. This seems to be a common thing with restaurants that are old they die out, the pizzas where not refilled the spaghettiwas awful it tasted like water and the meatballs where soggy. There options have dwindled, and the icecram and desserts were notwhat they used to be. I expected better for money I spent. Read more
We ate here today at 2:00pm. The pasta was dried out, the only 3 pizzas on the buffet were like rocks, no napkins on any table,... no ice for drinks and mold in the ice despenser. Did I mention the unmarked salad dressing bottles on the salad bar and thebrown lettuce? Dirty floors really rounded out this visit. Not likely to return. Read more
Even though they just raised their prices, it's still a good value. They staff is very nice and will make a special pizza when... eating at the buffet. My one negative is that they use too much salt in their food. Read more
We used to like eating here; however this last visit was terrible. Lunch at 1:01 pasta was dried, salad brown and I guess... iceberg lettuce is the new thing no more mixed green. None of the tables had napkins, my husband had to go ask for them. Youwould have thought she would have taken the initiative to make sure all the tables had them but no. Hope the take care of theissues. Read more
So, the first time I visited was for the buffet. Well, the lasagna was cold. The meat of whatever kind it was in the salad bar... was gross. The salad bar wasn't very good as far as selections go. Pizza was good. Those cannolis were the worst thing I've putin my face. And the Christian music blasting rounded up my not so good of an experience. I'm not a bigot but to alienate peoplewith being forced to listed to that is not okay in my humble opinion. Later I ordered in a couple "Panini" sandwiches fordelivery. A Panini grill is used to make Paninis. I got cibatta bread sandwiches. Suffice it to say, next time I'm in that areaof WV, I will not be returning. Read more
Montese's is a semi monthly, minimum, go-to spot with my family. We generally visit on Sunday after church or occasionally mid... week when all the kids want is pizza. The buffet hits every time we're there. It's super affordable, is always clean, salad baris always fresh, and they keep a quality assortment of pizzas hot fresh even when slammed on a Sunday during the church rush.The staff is always courteous, asking for any specialty pizza orders to add to the bar, and coming by to remove the dirtydishes. 10/10 recommend for anyone looking for quality pizza nonstop. Read more